Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

JoeBoredom t1_jbokftp wrote

Not a bug, it's the new community feature.

209

Goldrush02 t1_jboxb4f wrote

To be fair, it does seem like it wouldn't be a bad idea. A car rental service that you can just pick a car off the street and drive, rather than wait. Sounds like it MAY have issues catching on though.

5

MrGruntsworthy t1_jbpj1lz wrote

As a Tesla owner, I can tell you that this is wholesale impossible. You can not unlock a Tesla without the keycard, or a paired phone which requires the keycard set on the card reader to pair your phone during setup.

−5

HarryHacker42 t1_jbpnfaq wrote

You can turn on "PIN TO DRIVE" so you have to type in 1234 before you drive. I don't know if you can set other passwords, that's the only one I'd ever try.

35

masshiker t1_jbprqi1 wrote

I got in someone else's Honda civic with my civic key once.

26

Xendrus t1_jbpwcuu wrote

They'd both have to be basically spotless which makes sense in a new car, and the seat and mirrors would have to happen to be adjusted correctly and the color and model matching, I guess it's possible.

19

DoctorDiabolical_EvL t1_jbpxz07 wrote

This story is fake. Read the comments of the original post.

Edit: May not be fake, but delving into the story itself has several holes and the one who wrote the article has a suspect set of previous articles.

13

ash_274 t1_jbq4btf wrote

My grandfather and a stranger accidentally stole each other late-70s Ford Ranger pickups once. Same paint, same condition, even the same key pattern. He only realized it wasn't his when the fuel tank was lower than he expected and when he stopped at an intersection a pack of not-his-brand cigarettes slid out from under the seats. He drove to the sheriff's office and the other guy was already there. Everyone had a laugh and they got in their respective trucks and went on about their day.

109

sk8thow8 t1_jbq53ns wrote

You just have the next user inspect the vehicle for damages and report it before they start driving. And probably make people take pictures of the vehicle's condition when they drop it off. Plus, they have cameras in/on the vehicle.

3

twinheight t1_jbq5se6 wrote

Maybe you did mean "drive", and not "move". Otherwise, moving a vehicle without keys (or keycard) is not the same as driving the vehicle. Would you please elaborate on your claim?

2

Factsaretheonlytruth t1_jbqc30h wrote

I had something similar happen to me in the late 1980's. I went to pick up my silver Toyota Supra from the dealer after it had been serviced and got a few blocks away before I noticed stuff in the back that wasn't mine...because the car wasn't. I drove it back to the dealer to switch for mine and everyone there was amazed that this was even possible.

1

CaptainJackVernaise t1_jbqcjsv wrote

I guess we'll see if this shows up as the next car-stealing challenge on social media?

2

Toloc42 t1_jbqd028 wrote

There is one scenario where I can make this make sense. And that scenario has a lot of guesswork since I don't know the exact start up procedure of a Tesla car.

If the car unlocks and starts as long as the linked phone has connectivity, and stays drivable without further confirmation for a short time window after getting out and back in for convenience, then, if the owner of the other car had just gotten out and was still close enough, this might have been possible.

I do not know if Tesla cars work this way or can be configured to work this way.

Then the guy didn't get in because of an app mix up, but anyone else could've done it too. It's hard to imagine the other driver not noticing it though. Maybe if the second owner stood next to the first car, because they were confused too?

I'd believe a lot about the quality of Tesla cars, they don't have the best rep anymore, but the app actually unlocking a car next to the one it's actually linked to? No. That's beyond any level of incompetence.

12

EggCouncilCreeps t1_jbqioea wrote

Let's go to the 90s. We had just bought a brand new Nissan yesterday. First new car the family ever had (everything else was used) thanks to Unky's job at Nissan and the company discount. We walk out of Ross, click the unlock on the fob (ooo! Neat new feature!), open the door, sit down, and get ready to drive away. Look around. This doesn't look correct. Look right, there's a woman absolutely dumbfounded staring at me through the window. I look down. Shit. This isn't our car.

Thank gouda we don't live in Texas we mighta got shot. We got out, apologized, clicked the beeper and our car (right next to the one we got in what with that identical exterior trim) beeped. I like living where people are chill with honest mistakes.

2

FawltyPython t1_jbqls0o wrote

I unlocked another person's vw rabbit with my key once.

2

plumzki t1_jbqnigb wrote

Here in the Netherlands the are countless companies doing exactly this, we don't have a car but if we need to drive somewhere there is a car parked about 5 mins from us, we use an app to unlock it so no fucking around having to get it from somebody else, just jump in, do what we need and drop it back off. For a short trip this might cost us 10 to 15eu

1

EmptyAirEmptyHead t1_jbqnitz wrote

Tesla's have a key card as well (like a credit card). Odds are the owner of the car left the key card in it, car will never lock then. New guy walks up, does 'unlock' in his app and opens the door. Presto he thinks he unlocked the car. He did not.

11

iordseyton t1_jbqxjjw wrote

Back in the 80s or 90s, Toyota would only actually have like 150- 250. Different keys/ locks for any given run of cars. Dealerships would buy packs that were each key and could figure out the right one based on Vin (iirc)

As luck would have it, in our small town, there was one other guy with a red 86 Toyota pickup, and his and my dad's had the same key.

To make matters worse, they both worked with boats (my dad built them, and the other guy was a fisherman we think)

Occasionally, when launching a boat or doing something at the marina, when we came back at the end of the day, the other guy would have taken my dad's car home for the night. So my dad would just take it home for the night, then drop it back off in the parking lot first the next day, and get his back when the guy came back for it.

It happened 3 or 4 times that I know of- first time was a surprise when we came back from a sail, My dad reached under the seat for a fresh pack of smokes, as he pulled out of the lot, and came up with a fishing knife instead.

82

l30 t1_jbr49aj wrote

I had this happen with a 98' Toyota Tacoma. Same make/model/year and even the key. Found a guy sitting in the passenger seat waiting for his friend who had the exact same truck. Blew my mind.

2

ScattyWilliam t1_jbr6akl wrote

Never new of different keys starting vehicles but was definitely some 80’s imports (Asian) that often had door keys that worked on different vehicles. When we learnt this in high school there was some shenanigans

8

Cindexxx t1_jbr9tvi wrote

I found one car that was an entirely different brand that locked when I unlocked my car. Nothing else did anything, but it would do the usual locking beep if I clicked it twice.

2

this_1_is_mine t1_jbrctqw wrote

Ford had around 30 different door key cuts in the same time frame. The likelihood you could open any passing Ford was pretty high. Made working opening lockouts a pretty easy but not too time consuming task to do. But in the days of 2 keys to open and then start it was still pretty secure cause even of your door key worked the ignition key probably wouldn't.

20

cofclabman t1_jbrd07q wrote

All the older cars had few different keys. I was at a wedding and someone locked their keys in their car so we just had all the guests try their keys and found one that unlocked the car within 10 people.

8

Riverrat423 t1_jbreqsp wrote

Can I get the Tesla app, when I don’t own a Tesla? Then I can steal a Tesla.

1

Earth_Normal t1_jbrr59z wrote

I sat in the wrong old Nissan pickup once. All the keys are the same (worn out and basically worthless). I even started the truck before I noticed. Truck was the same color and trim. I only notice when the engine sounded worse.

Nobody noticed but I had a laugh.

2

CptUnderpants- t1_jbrrq58 wrote

>A Vancouver man is trying to figure out how he managed to get into someone else’s Tesla recently and drive off

It's easy to figure out. The car was left in valet mode by the owner, a mode which is meant to only be used in lieu of handing a key to a valet. So it wasn't 'unlocked with their app', it already was unlocked and ready to drive. This is no different to someone leaving their keys in the ignition of a normal car.

7

watertowertoes t1_jbs081x wrote

Take a Tesla, leave a Tesla. Free Little Car Exchange.

2

mkizer7 t1_jbs0mtg wrote

I had a red 1962 VW Bug in high school, when they were everywhere. I came out of work one day, unlocked my door, and started it up. I reached over to turn on the radio and had a weird deja vu-like disorientation as I realized that it wasn't my aftermarket stereo. Then I started looking around and noticing some other small differences (mine was mostly stock). It only took a few seconds to realize it wasn't my car.

I quickly shut it off, jumped out, and locked it up. I took a nervous look around to see if anyone thought I was stealing their car. Whew, nobody around. I then saw my car (I checked the plate number this time) just a few more spots further down the row in the parking lot. That was certainly an odd feeling. I guess those old VW keys weren't all that unique. 😀

3

bilateralrope t1_jbsbrd8 wrote

My dad once owned a car where the door locks were so worn out that anything vaguely key-shaped would unlock them. The ignition had flanges around it so you didn't even need a key.

​

It only got stolen once before my dad decided to replace it with something new enough to require rear seatbelts.

1

magick_68 t1_jbskqww wrote

I was shopping with my dad. Went back to the old mercedes we had back then, opened the door and kinda wondered why everything looked so different. That was ca. 30 years ago.

It is nice to see that one thing didn't change over three decades, the "fuck security" attitude of the car manufacturers.

1

L0nz t1_jbsmcfz wrote

The key card is NFC and has a very short range. Leaving it in the car won't allow someone else to drive your car, it has to be touched against a specific part of the centre console before you can select a gear, and it's unlikely to stay on that part of the console during transit. I'm not buying this explanation

2

L0nz t1_jbsmr8f wrote

It says he received a text from the other owner who found his phone number on a document in his car (implying that the other guy could get into his car somehow too). Why would you text someone who took your car, rather than call them?

Nothing about this story sounds legit, but shitting on tesla is so hot right now so obviously it's international news

−1

BardicSense t1_jbsro9l wrote

Most people commenting about the guy, but it seems like the Tesla is the real piece of garbage in this scenario.

1

spoonfight69 t1_jbt69lb wrote

Imagine paying $100,000 for this level of quality and security. Tesla drivers are rubes.

1

alexanderpas t1_jbtd2ec wrote

> Why would you text someone who took your car, rather than call them?

To cover your ass, and ensure the message arrived, instead of having the call declined because it was an unknown number

3

Folsomdsf t1_jbti6vz wrote

We drove it lol. It's really pretty easy to force a tesla into bypass mode. Now you're aware how they get stolen and parted out. Don't use an electronic system that can be failed open!

1

jimi15 t1_jbwqrc2 wrote

Think top gear proved that some of those automatic immobilisers are highly unreliable and sometimes lets you drive away without a key in the ignition. So i can believe it.

1

Cherryxizz t1_jc1kfak wrote

My mom did this with an old van. Unlocked got in started then realized it was too clean inside to be hers. Hera was a couple cars over.

1

BEHEMOTHpp t1_jc1q8c6 wrote

"Hello there ladies and gentlemen! I am The Spiffing Brit and today we are going to be breaking Tesla! That's right, we have found a way to unlock and sell any Tesla car for infinite money! This is not a joke, this is a 100% legit exploit that works on any Tesla model. All you need is a cup of tea, a screwdriver and a lot of patience. Watch as I show you how to hack into Elon Musk's secret network and access his personal inventory of Teslas. Then, I will show you how to sell them on eBay for millions of dollars each! This is the ultimate Tesla money glitch that will make you richer than Jeff Bezos! So sit back, relax and enjoy this perfectly balanced video with no exploits!"

5