Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

brownredgreen t1_j7g4n94 wrote

Reply to comment by queensnyatty in Tired of parking placard abuse? The DOT is holding a public hearing on some new rules that target parking placard abuse in loading zones on the 7th, and there aren't nearly enough comments. You can comment on the site, via email, or attend the hearing. by ThoolooExpress

Strikes are never illegal.

Strikes are workers putting down their tools.

Telling someone it's illegal to put down their tools? Sounds like slavery.

Fuck Reagan.

2

snakopaks t1_j7i5t4q wrote

Are you familiar with the Taylor Law

Setting aside what's "right", public-sector strikes are illegal in New York. The flipside is union contracts continue in perpetuity when a new one isn't negotiated (the "Triborough Amendment"), unlike in the private sector. It creates a strong status quo bias.

2

WikiSummarizerBot t1_j7i5uow wrote

Taylor Law

>The Public Employees Fair Employment Act, more commonly known as the Taylor Law, is Article 14 of the New York State Civil Service Law, which defines the rights and limitations of unions for public employees in New York. The Public Employees Fair Employment Act (the Taylor Law) is a New York State statute, named after labor researcher George W. Taylor. It authorizes a governor-appointed State Public Employment Relations Board to resolve contract disputes for public employees while curtailing their right to strike. The law provides for mediation and binding arbitration to give voice to unions, but work stoppages are made punishable with fines and jail time.

^([ )^(F.A.Q)^( | )^(Opt Out)^( | )^(Opt Out Of Subreddit)^( | )^(GitHub)^( ] Downvote to remove | v1.5)

2

brownredgreen t1_j7i708s wrote

Slavery was permitted by The State.

It was always wrong, always immoral.

If you cant stop working, you are a slave. Currently, barring a criminal conviction in a court, slavery is not allowed in the US.

2

snakopaks t1_j7ibklp wrote

Yes, slavery was and is immoral. You said illegal though, not immoral. Folks are of course free to quit their jobs, they don't have to keep working for the government. A strike is a little more specific than that.

1

snakopaks t1_j7ibqpk wrote

Also if you don't like that it's illegal, advocate for making it legal by repealing the Taylor Law

1

brownredgreen t1_j7ibw95 wrote

Is Moral Law, law?

Is a white horse, a horse?

If the Moral Law, is Law, then strikes are never illegal

If Moral Law is not Law, then white horses arent horses.

1

snakopaks t1_j7ilebd wrote

In New York, apparently not. I support repealing the Taylor Law, sounds like you do too?

1

queensnyatty t1_j7g5g8c wrote

You are always free to quit. That’s what an illegal strike is—a bunch of civil servants quitting.

−2

brownredgreen t1_j7g5y6l wrote

In your mind, how's this different than a "legal" strike?

Isnt that also, from your view "a bunch of civil servants quitting"?

2

queensnyatty t1_j7g6btl wrote

One is legal and the other is illegal. That’s the difference.

If you are some kind of law doesn’t matter anarchist, what are you doing in a government job in the first place?

−3

brownredgreen t1_j7g6hu7 wrote

Immoral laws deserve no respect.

Not all laws are the same.

I also support runaway slaves. The moral law > the legal law

4

queensnyatty t1_j7g71yr wrote

So you’re saying you’ll happily suck off the public teat but the second it’s convenient for you, all of a sudden you’re Henry David Thoreau.

I got it, your values are whatever is best for you in the moment. Lots of people like that.

−2

brownredgreen t1_j7g76p5 wrote

You're a bad troll

The fact that you think moral law is "whatever is best for me in the moment" shows how absolutely idiotic you are.

0/10, wont reply again

1