Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

sidewaysrebel14 t1_jatvlgs wrote

For context that is $4 billion dollars on an annualized basis or $132,500 per migrant. Feels unsustainable - should either lower the cost to something manageable (read shelter housing not paid for hotel rooms in Manhattan, the most expensive place on earth) or move them upstate or better yet to the interior of the country where there’s a combination of labor shortages and cheaper cost of living

86

bittoxic00 t1_jatxcer wrote

You or I would need to earn, what, $170k per year on the books to realize the benefit of $132k. Whatever your views are there are people realizing much less and surviving in this city. Where is it all going

58

sidewaysrebel14 t1_jatxruq wrote

Hotel rooms mostly - same places that were used during the pandemic as homeless shelters. The hotels found out they can rent a room to the city for let’s say 400 a night with no need to turn it around or market or have empty rooms. Pretty much a bonanza for hotel owners in a down season for tourism

54

bittoxic00 t1_jau05rw wrote

That’s true, I would say give them low cost apartments in city housing but I feel that would just be a slap in the face for anyone already on those lists

14

fppencollector t1_jawj3wd wrote

Are these hotel owners planning to replace all the mattresses and bedding, and deep clean all the carpets and upholstery? Otherwise, I don't know how many tourists would visit NYC instead of another destination.

Despite the enormous monetary, logistical, and staffing burden on the city's government and ultimately the taxpayers, there is no appreciation for these provided resources from the beneficiaries.

At a recent city council meeting, Julie Won and Gale Brewer were pressing the HERRC staff on the quality of the food. Breakfast with milk and fresh fruit, prepared sandwiches for lunch and a hot dinner that is calorically and nutritionally sufficient is very reasonable. Religious and medical adjustments are accomodated.

Demands for meals that are culturally familiar, when there are people from multiple regions of the world is not a reasonable requirement. Specific meal Demands for chicken and rice is not reasonable.

My takeaway from the article:

Yet despite the city’s pleas for help from the Biden and Hochul administrations, it has gotten a drop in the bucket when it comes to financial help — even as the Big Apple barrels toward a projected $4.2 billion two-year total bill to handle the influx.

11

ifiwereaplatypus t1_jax82mk wrote

>Are these hotel owners planning to replace all the mattresses and bedding, and deep clean all the carpets and upholstery? Otherwise, I don't know how many tourists would visit NYC instead of another destination.

This statement assumes that migrants are "dirtier" than tourists. On the cartoonishly evil range, I rate this statement 9/10 on the CE scale.

8

fppencollector t1_jaxmarm wrote

That's why there are outbreaks occurring in NYC public schools stemming from children allowed to attend classes without vaccination records or titer tests.

12

ifiwereaplatypus t1_jaxt3gu wrote

The asylum seekers who are vaccinated at the border and then bussed to New York in a tax-payer funded political campaign by a sitting Republican governor are the cause of outbreaks of… what, exactly? Gonorrhea?

−4

fppencollector t1_jaxupqc wrote

https://nypost.com/2023/02/04/migrant-students-dont-need-to-show-proof-of-vaccinations/

The Simon Baruch Middle School in Gramercy Park had a chickenpox case, according to a Jan. 25 notice from the principal which said students not vaccinated for the illness could not attend school.

A parent at the school said after the announcement, five migrant children were absent for a few days from the class in question.

9

supermechace t1_jaz8t66 wrote

Also for real estate companies and owners who charge the city for housing the homeless and migrants. Take from the middle class and give to the wealthy

5

[deleted] t1_jawgibv wrote

[deleted]

22

Therealdirtyburdie t1_jay152j wrote

That would be crazy idea! Lol. Like Chuck Schumer said we need these migrants because Americans are not procreating Enough so we need migrants plus they all promised to become Democrats

6

Hrekires t1_jawjml2 wrote

Is that not what happens if they're not granted asylum?

1

[deleted] t1_jawp84j wrote

[deleted]

14

spicytoastaficionado t1_jay3uj6 wrote

Not necessarily.

It isn't like you are denied asylum and then immediately taken it into custody and deported.

3

supremeMilo t1_jay5p31 wrote

How about allowing them to legally work and giving them a plane ticket anywhere in the country to fill one of the 10,000,000 open jobs.

0

jonsconspiracy t1_jaz94wv wrote

Exactly this. They're already here and we need workers. I don't really understand the issue here. Let them all get jobs and start buying their own food and paying their own rent.

0

supremeMilo t1_jaz9c9g wrote

If they are legal, then they can’t be exploited for illegally low wages. (Republicans mad)

If they aren’t fed and housed grifters aren’t getting paid. (Democrats mad)

7

gsbound t1_jauty0a wrote

It doesn’t matter, taxes wouldn’t be any lower, and the city never spends money on anything useful anyways. De blasio slush fund, police lawsuits, cronies in city hall, spending 20x the normal price on a subway line. To me, it doesn’t matter whose pocket this money ends up in, hotel owners, Union bosses, Eric Adams, fuck you could even hand out 130k in cash to each migrant and my life wouldn’t change at all

7