Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

bherm100 t1_iu6ntsw wrote

Reply to comment by dagav in CDC Issues Warning as New Data Shows Scope of Polio Spread in NYC Area by brooklynlad

Jew here. Fuck these scumbags.

38

dagav t1_iu6phzn wrote

I'm wondering what kind of authority you think "Jew here" gives you. All it does it whitewash these sentiments for anti-semites.

−12

bherm100 t1_iu6pnwq wrote

It means that "Jewish identity" being some sort of monolith is hilariously dumb bullshit.

This guy doesn't speak for me or any other Jew. Fuck outa here with that garbage. Tribalism is for racists.

29

dagav t1_iu6xws8 wrote

If you reject the Jewish identity then why do you say "Jew here"? What does it mean to be a Jew exactly?

And how can you tell me I don't speak for any other Jews when that's precisely what you are doing when you say, "This guy doesn't speak for any other Jew"?

And why does your Jew card overrule mine? Not that I've even played mine, but I'm a Jew too. What gives you the right to say "Jew here" and try and overrule anything I might say about the Jewish identity, as if my opinion doesn't matter?

−6

Han-Shot_1st t1_iu6zgz7 wrote

And do you think all groups should engage in this kind of behavior? Run that thought experiment. What would the world be like?

7