Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Grass8989 t1_ixu694o wrote

“I’m appalled by our city’s failure to help the individuals who must resort to asking strangers for some cash or food, and the fact that homeless individuals sometimes need to sleep on the subway because homeless shelters are a less safe option than sleeping on the street or on the train.”

Except the city does provide food for these people, it’s nearly impossible to go hungry in this city. The sad reality is the majority of pan handlers are addicts/and or mentally ill, and not typical “down on their luck” homeless. The vast majority of the homeless population in this city, also, do utilize the shelter system. Its a small subset that choose to (attempt) to live in the subway and on the streets.

Also her “commute” is from upper Manhattan to Columbus Circle, not exactly the average NYers commute. This author seems pretty naive and out of touch, tbh.

All she had to do was say she was “very satisfied” (ie. it’s not something that she regularly deals with or experiences), instead of virtue signaling about how she feels her lived experience is representative of everyone’s.

5

k1lk1 t1_ixu6u82 wrote

I'm sure she also feels sorry for the guys begging in traffic on the Deegan, you know, because they're going to buy beans with that money and not fentanyl.

5

Koboldsftw t1_ixudyfl wrote

You would be a mentally ill addict too if you had to live on the street for a while

4

EdgeOrnery6679 t1_ixui3bl wrote

Most of them are addicts before being homeless. I know my dad had to kick his brother, my uncle out of the house because he kept stealing money/ things to sell so he can buy crack. He refused to go to rehab or get any help so hes out there homeless and we dont know what happened to him. Im sure thats how many of these addicts are homeless.

1

Koboldsftw t1_ixuihyg wrote

Why are you sure? I work with and talk to a lot of homeless people in the city and this is not very common.

3

Grass8989 t1_ixuijbl wrote

Many of them burn bridges with their families/friends, it’s sad but it usually starts with addiction, which leads to homelessness. These aren’t people who were dutiful members of society who suddenly lost their job and are now getting high and harassing people on the subway for money.

−5