You don't mention whether *you* want to move out. What does rent closer to the new job look like. If *you* want to move out and rent near the new job is reasonable, you can take the increased salary and have a short commute.

I made the decision to accept a long commute for less of a salary increase (but still significant) and ended up staying at that job for years and really liking it. I didn't move near the new job, but I did eventually find a good paying job closer to home.

There are a lot of other factors that go into the decision, but with only the information you've given here, it sounds like you should take the new job.