Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

WhiskyIsMyYoga t1_j6kycf3 wrote

I’ve bike commuted in San Diego, San Francisco, Boston, Dresden, London, Cardiff, and Philadelphia.

Philly is hands down the most dangerous place I’ve ever ridden a bicycle. The infrastructure is appallingly bad, save for a select few locations which are islands of relative safety amongst the sea of negligently dangerous streets. It doesn’t have to be this bad.

155

LowPermission9 t1_j6kytno wrote

It’s not wonderful but at least there are bike lanes in many parts of Philly. The minute you cross city borders into the suburbs the bike lanes become nonexistent.

58

hdhcnsnd OP t1_j6l0ao6 wrote

The majority of bike lanes here are low quality (non-protected, usually in the door zone, occasionally inches from high speed traffic).

If you look at the 1/22 and 1/27 cyclist murders, both took place along streets with bike lanes. Without further details, I would presume both cyclists were riding in the bike lanes when they were killed.

This is the horrifying part. Our infrastructure is a painted line— maybe it makes you feel safe but there’s nothing stopping a car from crossing it. Bike lanes need to be protected or separated from cars or this will continue to happen.

This is pretty standard practice in NYC/SF/DC/Boston and miles ahead in Europe.

92

mortgagepants t1_j6mwa5a wrote

harrisburg made a law that in all of pennsylvania, you can't have parking separating bike lines on any state roads. they have to make the lanes in the door zone. (spring garden, broad, etc.)

14

courageous_liquid t1_j6nrnul wrote

Spring garden is going to be parking protected.

It's also not that harrisburg made a law, it's just that the way our streets are codified requires cars to be parked next to the curb. Parking protected bike lanes are "pilots" that PennDOT grants because they realize it would require a pretty heavy political lift from our insane state legislature to change the code.

2

mortgagepants t1_j6nsluc wrote

"Parking-separated bike lanes have historically been barred on state-owned roadways because Pennsylvania law requires parked vehicles to be within 12 inches of the curb, or the edge of the pavement." Although this is(was) technically the law for all roads in PA.

https://bicyclecoalition.org/pa-senate-committee-amends-parking-protected-bike-lane-bill-with-anti-municipal-amendment/

not disagreeing with you, just adding some nuance in case anyone else is following along.

6

courageous_liquid t1_j6nys6u wrote

Correct, thank you. I figured that bill was going to either get killed or poison pilled but never followed up, appreciate the article.

Pennsyltucky never fails to amaze me with their absolute braindead politics.

4

Booplympics t1_j6lh4qr wrote

> If you look at the 1/22 and 1/27 cyclist murders

Murders?

Hmmm downvotes but nobody explaining how it’s murder. Interesting.

−26

Norman_Door t1_j6lowjn wrote

This tragedy could probably be best classified as a homicide, not a murder.

My guess is that the people downvoting you because they are under the impression that you're trying to imply this is not a "murder" but an "accident."

11

Booplympics t1_j6lxix5 wrote

It is not murder. It is an accident. It’s also homicide. But homicide does not equal murder. These are indisputable facts.

Unless, of course, OP has proof that these were premeditated acts. In which case no amount of bike infrastructure would have stopped it and it would be weird to use such an unrelated act to push your agenda.

−8

Norman_Door t1_j6mq39o wrote

I agree with you on the murder part. It's the wrong word to use. Too often, however, these deaths are referred to as "accidents" by the media, which downplays the culpability of the driver in the cyclist's death.

11

ConfiaEnElProceso t1_j6l1o99 wrote

Yeah, the suburbs need better bike infrastructure as well.

But if you think Philly is safer, lanes or not, you are way off.

I live in the city and bike commute to the burbs every day. Yeah, i have to plan my way around crazy 4 lane roads with 35-45 mph speed limits, but the side streets are way, way, way safer than any side street in philly.

33

LowPermission9 t1_j6lh8bg wrote

This is true about the side streets. Still, the main roads are rough. I live right on Montgomery Ave in a 25mph zone where the minimum most people drive is 35-40. Also it’s 2 lanes each way with no shoulder. Same for Lancaster Ave. tbh, I’d rather bike on Columbus or Washington than here.

13

AbsentEmpire t1_j6n40ej wrote

Most of the bike lanes in this city are so bad they might as well not exist in practice.

I find biking in the suburbs to actually be safer most of the time because the streets are so wide cars pass you with enough space.

Drivers are also held to a higher degree of accountability in burbs since the cops there actually enforce traffic laws.

Worst case you can bike on the sidewalks and use them as a properly designed separated bike lane, because no fat ass in the suburbs walks, so they're always empty.

8

LowPermission9 t1_j6no5j9 wrote

I was about to admonish you for riding on the sidewalk until I got to your rationalization, and then I just laughed.

2

AbsentEmpire t1_j6noeh9 wrote

Ya, I don't bike on sidewalks in the city, people are actually walking on them.

I actually just don't bike all that much at all anymore, since the lock downs the drivers have gotten even worse and I just don't feel safe biking in the city anymore.

5

mortgagepants t1_j6mw3ii wrote

that's literally by design. the whole point of the suburbs is they don't want city people coming to them.

3

LowPermission9 t1_j6nofg3 wrote

Yup! There’s a new mixed use and dense development happening in Newtown Square designed for walkability. You should see the comments of shock and disgust on Nextdoor.

7

ConfiaEnElProceso t1_j6ldcfu wrote

It's bad. I bike commuted in Brooklyn before NYC started putting in bike lanes and it was still much safer than philly. Charlotte is a horrific suburban hellscape and there are roads you have to avoid, but it was safer overall. I think Medellin, Colombia might be worse. More protected bike paths but the roads and drivers and mopeds are probably worse

21

Least_Way t1_j6mw12l wrote

Atlanta is so much worse than Philly, worse traffic, worse drivers, somehow even less police enforcement, and way fewer bike lanes.

13

ten-million t1_j6l616x wrote

If I make it to work on my bike I’ll say, I didn’t die today. Because most days it seems pretty easy to die on Philly streets.

15

SpecialistSoup198 t1_j6l4xja wrote

Philly is pretty bad but worse I've seen is surprisingly Honolulu. but yea I basically only bike the trails in Philly cause I've seen and heard of too many cyclists getting hit, even when they're in the bike lanes. worst part about Philly is a lot of the drivers who would hit a cyclist would probably drive away

13

ToughLittleTomato t1_j6l72ca wrote

I have bike commuted in Honolulu, too. It wasn't great.... Philly is certainly up there as one of the worst places to bike. Based on my personal experience, Jersey City and NYC are worse. Jersey City has few bike lanes, the roads are shit, and drivers frequently blow through stops.

America was designed for cars, unfortunately.

7

DixonWasAliveAgain t1_j6liicc wrote

Philadelphia wasn’t designed for cars - and neither were Jersey City or NYC for that matter. They’ve been badly retrofitted for cars, and it shows. These are all cities built for walking within neighborhoods and public transportation between neighborhoods. Philadelphia’s over-reliance on cars despite the way its actually built is a policy choice that costs us in time, money, and safety every day.

38

throwawaitnine t1_j6kzwrz wrote

If you ask me, SF is way way worse than Philly, like 100x worse imo. But also that was like 15 years ago, and things have got pretty bad here in Philly.

11

Laserdollarz t1_j6ldiwh wrote

Here in Denver, the ghost bike memorials for fatal bicycle incidents get hit by cars. Nobody even stops. Shit is scary.

15

WhiskyIsMyYoga t1_j6mnrr0 wrote

It’s also dependent where in the city you are. I was going back and forth between Burlingame, so the routes were pretty easy and protected.

2