Submitted by BernardJOrtcutt t3_11qaiuh in philosophy
These-Shop-1716 t1_jdshpyk wrote
Reply to comment by MountainSimple24 in /r/philosophy Open Discussion Thread | March 13, 2023 by BernardJOrtcutt
What exactly do you mean by preservation? In a biological sense, I would disagree with you. Animals (including humans) have the urge to self-preserve because it's evolutionary beneficial. Animals who want to survive are more likely to survive, cells and RNA reproduce for that same reason. Not because there is a god or because it's the meaning of the universe but simply because of natural selection.
"The universe preserves itself just by being itself"
How is that the case? Just because something exists, it doesn't mean it preserves.
MountainSimple24 t1_jdykgeh wrote
I think get your point, however, to say it’s ‘evolutionarily beneficial’, implies there is a driving force, whether you want to call it God or Meaning, you’ve provided a driving force. It’s like saying natural selections goal is to survive. Natural selection makes better survivors survive, but doesn’t make things survive.
What I was trying to say was more a recognition of a pattern and a hopeful attempt at extrapolating the pattern to all things. Maybe incorrect, but hopeful, that the universe would perpetuate itself by means of its very being. Foolish, but hopeful.
How I came to this was via stating that humans preserve themselves by living. A human who decides to live, makes the conscious decisions that extend their life. They arnt trying to extend it, it’s simply a bi-product of them living. Choosing to find shelter and food is to satisfy hunger and comfort but I don’t think people shop with “yes this will extend my life” in mind.
So the claim I was making, is that if humans and animals and cells, and maybe DNA and RNA, extend their lives not by trying to, but just by existing in their own ways, that possibly, all things extend their own existence as a byproduct of their existence. Maybe, just maybe, all things further their existence not by choosing to, but as a side effect of existence. For if not, then you would simply cease to exist whenever you weren’t trying to exist.
Thoughts?
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments