Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

_Zirath_ OP t1_j2pxly4 wrote

Reply to comment by Ill_Sound621 in Atheistic Naturalism does not offer any long-term pragmatic outcome of value when compared to Non-Naturalist views, such as Theism by _Zirath_

Not the same premises or conclusion, but you still think they're the same argument. Haha ok. I'll just refer you over to the other more interesting comment thread I had on this.

1

Ill_Sound621 t1_j2pxv09 wrote

I'm more interesting in knowing if You realise that You never talk about Theism here???.

Have someone told You that???

1

_Zirath_ OP t1_j2pylqr wrote

This argument only posits theism as an example of a potential alternative and really doesn't care about the truth or falsity of theism. Like I said, I'll just refer you elsewhere in this thread because you just don't seem to understand:

https://www.reddit.com/r/philosophy/comments/100zfxn/atheistic_naturalism_does_not_offer_any_longterm/j2lln47/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

1

Ill_Sound621 t1_j2pyyg4 wrote

But You based your definition of naturalism by using this (false) definition of theism. The minus infinite stuff and all that jazz.

1