If you have your Venmo set up to a bank a/c (assuming), I’d subsequently call your bank and see if they can trace the money. My mom worked for PNC, and Pittsburgh National Bank before that, so she’s in my ear constantly about all the scams/fraud going on today bc she knows how it’s only increased and her years of experience haha. Just a suggestion - bc the bank will obviously have access you won’t and you’re not the only person these people have come after, so the police can notify whomever they need to.