Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Itsjustataco t1_j2n936b wrote

Why would we bother to allow this?just seems to be valueless to me

1

Delicious-Newt-5674 OP t1_j2ncyzf wrote

Probably cause the guy who submitted it is from Bradford where case knives is. However it passed pretty much unanimously.

3

IOnlyLurk t1_j2nygbe wrote

Because the law also made it illegal to sell or repair these knives. Which meant businesses had to leave PA or not be able to compete in that market.

Also we can carry guns. Banning a certain type of knife from being carried is stupid.

3

hubbyofhoarder t1_j2xrmdw wrote

Because the switchblade distinction was arbitrary and ridiculous. There are a ton of folding knives made today that one can open with just a flick of a thumb or finger. Those knives open every bit as quickly as any automatic knife, and yet were not illegal.

The old law also made no distinction for knives that were clearly used for legitimate purposes. My mother was a career HS teacher who travelled to Italy a few times. On one of her trips she brought home a switchblade; the blade was an inch and a half long. Mom kept it in her purse and used it to cut the fruit she brought for her lunch. Should she have been charged? That's ridiculous

My mother was not going to throw down a la the Sharks and the Jets with other teachers in the parking lot.

1