Info: who told you you look “okay” without makeup? Has your bf ever expressed any sort of feeling like this?

Based on your post as written, it sounds as if you’re taking him being enthusiastic about you in makeup as a criticism of you outside of makeup? Rather than talking to him about it

If that is actually the case, my advice is to talk to him about it

If he is blatantly trying to tell you you’re only attractive in makeup, I’d personally opt out of that relationship myself but it really depends on how you feel about it