Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

berrytas t1_je3m1il wrote

search 'healthy user bias' - that's all this is. epidemiology is very weak evidence of anything


NightsOvercast t1_je55ht8 wrote

How do you see healthy user bias playing a part in this specific study?


berrytas t1_je5aiy0 wrote

vegans are more likely to be 'rule followers' and engage in other lifestyle behaviors that are considered healthy (e.g., more walks, exercise, less processed foods, generally taking care of oneself). their positive health outcomes may or may not be related to their diet.

it has been shown repeatedly that you cannot control for these confounding lifestyle factors - hence why epidemiology should be step 1, and then you use randomized controlled trials to actually test for only changes in diet (which is obviously very hard to do at any sort of scale over any long time horizon - can't really lock people away for decades).

additionally, comparing a vegan diet consisting of whole, fresh foods to the standard american diet isn't really telling. anything is better than that!