Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

IFuckedYourDadd t1_isth5hg wrote

Do people in these comments not know how genes work? Obviously the ones that aren't stillborn may still carry the genetics to have stillborn babies.

Some women have a stillbirth the first time, then have a successful birth the second time for example.

177

MinerMinecrafter t1_istu50b wrote

Isn't that basically the first thing you learn about genes at middle school?

34

IFuckedYourDadd t1_istu981 wrote

Yeah. But I mean its reddit, probably have a lot of drop outs on here

32

MinerMinecrafter t1_istuec7 wrote

And 10 year olds that are not supposed to be here

19

asdaaaaaaaa t1_iswmyfp wrote

People highly overestimate the average age of people on reddit I'd imagine (and how many of them are actual people). I wouldn't be surprised if the average age was around 14 or so, like a lot of other online games/groups. Looking at certain popular comments, it's pretty clear sometimes many people here have never held a more career-oriented job, or done a decent chunk of "normal adult things".

3

PfizerGuyzer t1_isucm1e wrote

Reddit has many Americans, whose education system unfortunately has them retain almost none of the information they learn for more than a day after the exam.

13

EastTyne1191 t1_isvjcuz wrote

Learning, sure. But retaining AND applying that information 15-20 years later? That's a tall order.

9

Mediocre_American t1_isu02u3 wrote

Nah, I didn’t learn about genes until 10th grade high school. And it was barely the basics. Had to relearn everything from uni or the internet.

4

MinerMinecrafter t1_isu0jt7 wrote

What, I learned about genes at 6th grade primary school for the first time and then again at 9th grade

3

D20Jawbreaker t1_isv1mzd wrote

I also didn’t learn of them til 10th and my teacher barely knew how to form a sentence. Wouldn’t let us use the word ‘things’ in her class it was trippy.

6

MountainDewde t1_isw9nze wrote

That stillbirths can occur, or that siblings of stillborn babies carry the same genes? I don't think stillbirths were mentioned when I first heard of genetics.

1

Rocketboy1313 t1_isus89g wrote

It is still possible to criticize the way they word things.

For instance, "a predisposition for stillbirths may be genetic" covers everything they want to reasonable levels.

5

YamaKazeRinZen t1_iswyz7b wrote

Some fact that should be mentioned, first pregnancy with a specific male has a higher chance of stillbirth or complication because the mother’s immune system need to learn adapting

1

AltruisticAcadia9366 t1_istmh0d wrote

but how does the mother inherit the gene from her brother?

−5

m674 t1_istodft wrote

She doesn't, she inherits it from her father, the same person the brother inherited it from. However, if the mother has a child, the "gene" for stillbirth for that child will come from the infant's father, not the mother. However, if her brother has a child, his child will have his stillbirth "gene".

If the woman noticed her husband's brother (brother in law) has multiple stillbirth infants, this would be more concerning than if she noticed the same thing with her brother.

33

Outside_Classroom_38 t1_isvmnfe wrote

Thank you for being able to kindly explain this. I didn’t have the same patience after reading some of these comments.

1