Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Thepinkknitter t1_iumlpg7 wrote

9

MechaMagikarp t1_iummssb wrote

The ten commandments are not the top ten rules. They are literally the ten subjects that all other sin falls into. The “sins” that you are comparing to “mortal sin” are one in the same. Scholars from Christianity and Judaism regularly group those “lesser sins” in with the commandment that they relate to. Why? Because the ten commandments are just the major overlying principles that you MUST abide by. The lessers are quite literally variations of those commandments. Sorry but absolutely no.

0

Thepinkknitter t1_iumnfey wrote

Somebody skipped religion class. Feel free to read up on the difference between mortal sins and venial sins.

https://stboniface-lunenburg.org/mortal-and-venial-sin

3

MechaMagikarp t1_iumpijd wrote

My bad. I didn’t realize we were only talking about the Catholic view of the Ten Commandments. I was most definitely referring to the real view of the book. Not any one of the three’s deeply opinionated views on it.

−3

Thepinkknitter t1_iumq1en wrote

Right, you talk about religion, say for a fact that all sins in the Bible are treated the exact same way, but OH you conveniently forgot about the second largest religious body in the world. Wild.

4

JazzyWarthog t1_iuox7vu wrote

Catholicism doesn't exactly have a reputation to stick to the Bible's rules, quite frankly. What Catholicism says isn't always what the Bible states.

In this case all sins are treated equally per the Bible, with the only unforgivable one being blaspheming the holy spirit.

1