could_use_a_snack t1_jan4xdm wrote
Reply to comment by CptHammer_ in NASA’s DART data validates kinetic impact as planetary defense method | DART altered the orbit of the asteroid moonlet Dimorphos by 33 minutes by mepper
>Which is probably why you support more funding. We haven't perfected the weapon yet.
Your statement shows that you are just trying to troll me. They did hit the target. Perfectly. Physics just makes it really hard to overcome an error. This will never be used as a weapon. It can't be.
I hope that you are either still in school and haven't taken basic 9th grade physics yet or have just forgotten what you have learned.
Either way, If you would like to have a reasonable conversation on this topic, you seem to be worried and I could help you understand that you don't need to be, I would suggest you brush up on orbital mechanics, and the launch capabilities that we currently have. Until then have a great day.
CptHammer_ t1_jaounbm wrote
>This will never be used as a weapon. It can't be.
You're saying basically it's impossible to do what they did. And you seem to also think that practice doesn't make perfect.
>I hope that you are either still in school and haven't taken basic 9th grade physics yet or have just forgotten what you have learned.
I've taught physics at a collegic level. This is barely a physics problem and more of an economic problem. We already know we can divert astroids, how much will it cost to put it where we want it?
You're probably unaware of proposals to aim astroids into a Mars orbit for mining. Mars orbit before lunar orbit just to prove we won't make accidents. Lunar orbits rather than earth orbits because we actually don't need much material back on earth. Only to replace the materials we sent to space. And of course it's an extra risk.
The idea of mining astroids in place is too dangerous and too costly as it's simply easier to bring things to the mill rather than moving mining operations so often. It's why we don't build a saw mill in every tree grove for lumber production, we move the logs to the mill.
could_use_a_snack t1_jap1qve wrote
You make some good points.
This is not what they did however. They didn't aim an asteroid anywhere. They caused it to change its orbit.
Yes you can move an asteroid to orbit a planet, but it will take years to do this. Making several minor adjustments over a long period of time. Not a great way to fire a weapon if everyone can see what you are doing for 3 years.
And the mill towns I've seen (I live in one that isn't one anymore) are always right next to the forest, if not in the middle. Moving huge trees is costly, you mill them as close to the source as possible and then transport the finished product to its destination.
And. If you did teach physics, I feel sorry for your students, anyone that doesn't want to see science funded shouldn't be teaching it.
CptHammer_ t1_japefzp wrote
>Not a great way to fire a weapon if everyone can see what you are doing for 3 years.
I don't think they're trying to hide it. Did you skip past the part where I said putting them in lunar orbit? It would take a push of the button at precisely the right time to send one to earth. Once they've been reduced to the appropriate size for the deviation they want to cause.
Even worse is if I'm wrong and a government isn't behind it but a terrorist. I'm telling you any perceived good is outweighed by the inevitable bad.
could_use_a_snack t1_jaq2wgn wrote
Wait, are you suggesting that what would amount to a trillion dollar industry capable of getting multiple asteroids into orbit around the moon, will be accomplished by a terrorist organization?
I'm done talking to you. You are just being ridiculous now.
CptHammer_ t1_jaqo8hh wrote
No, I'm saying once the benevolent portion of the plan is finished a terrorist could turn it into a weapon. I don't care how benevolent a plan you suggest any new technology will be weaponized.
It's like you're trying to suggest terrorists invented bombs with their own R&D to come to the conclusion you did.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments