Submitted by Boss452 t3_11bf3ri in television
monsieurxander t1_j9z9pz5 wrote
Reply to comment by StannisLivesOn in Game of Thrones Season 4 has to be in the GOAT discussion. by Boss452
It's not a real quote. Someone misquoted them as they were live-tweeting an event, and publications ran with it. When the audio turned up with what they actually said, those publications didn't rush to correct themselves. What they actually said:
>“With the fantasy genre on television, tonally it’s very easy [go too] campy. Every scene, you change these two lines and it’s Monty Python and the Holy Grail,” Weiss jokes. “Also, in terms of fantasy exposition, with proper nouns, it’s almost like a game of Jenga, where you’re trying to plow as many of them as possible without the whole thing falling over. In the first pilot, we had one too many and the whole thing fell over. Going forward, we tried to keep that stuff to a minimum, because we didn’t just want to appeal to a fantasy fanbase. We wanted them to love it, and we wanted our parents to love it, and people who play professional football to love it. We wanted to reach a wider audience, and to do that keeping the tone [under control] was very important.”
VitaminTea t1_ja238vw wrote
Even if it were a real quote, a show aiming to appeal a broad audience is not a bad thing.
drupoxy t1_j9zn57k wrote
There is a middle ground between Season 1 of the Witcher in which they absolutely do have too many "proper nouns" introduced for most viewers, and then whatever it was that they gave us. The key is being a good writer, so, ya know...
MissKhary t1_ja0atob wrote
I feel like The Witcher was confusing on purpose though with the timelines, it's like they wanted you to always be wondering "wtf was that about"
drupoxy t1_ja0fivq wrote
I was able to follow it without any issue because I had CC turned on. Without those, all of the jargon and names tossed at you are much harder to remember. So for example, if you see the queen's name in ep 1, it's pretty straightforward to connect the dots later in the show when they mention her in the past tense.
MissKhary t1_ja0gibd wrote
I had read the books and played games, and while I knew the storylines I still kept getting a bit tangled in the timelines. But then again the books with their short story format also jumped around. So while some things were obvious as different times, some things were only apparent in hindsight, even if I had some frame of reference that the average viewer would not have. So I think it HAD to be purposeful, because it was confusing even to me, but I only realized HOW confusing it was in the last episodes.
OathOfFeanor t1_ja3zdtb wrote
It may not be verbatim but that is still exactly what they said...literally the same message
monsieurxander t1_ja48296 wrote
Aside from the massive difference in tone... they're talking about fantasy vocabulary, not magic itself.
AH_BareGarrett t1_ja0pegl wrote
They wish their writing was half as good as Monty Pyrhon.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments