Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Enraiha t1_j8v5kt2 wrote

Fun for sure, but I wish they would've balanced the teams or challenges better. It's definitely been a fun one to watch.

53

Peelboy t1_j8v6xr3 wrote

I struggled with the first half of the first episode, but as it has continued, I have come to enjoy it more.

13

NeighborhoodLanky692 t1_j8va2e9 wrote

I watched half an episode and it felt sooooo slow. Like we’re just watching people hanging on the ceiling and it wasn’t very interesting.

9

Tana1234 t1_j8vjt5b wrote

I'm watching it and enjoying it but to call it "awesome" is a stretch its some dumb fun to watch, but the constant cliffhangers repeats of the same thing and overall premise is kinda dumb

−2

NeighborhoodLanky692 t1_j8vonza wrote

Feels like the show has serious pacing issues, I fast forwarded through a lot and saw that they played the same game from the end of ep 1 to the start of ep 4, and then spent almost 30 minutes just picking teams. The more intricate challenges are fun, I wish the show knew what to focus on.

6

TimeTimeTickingAway t1_j8vwbf6 wrote

For any MMA fans just know that you will be seeing Sexyama, and if that doesn't sell it for you, I don't know what will.

64

YoyoDevo t1_j8vzrhz wrote

It's hilarious how some of the women are so overconfident that they pick the biggest strongest guy to challenge and just get easily destroyed, and then are like "I'm proud of myself." No, you're an idiot.

30

kalvyn729 t1_j8wdvm3 wrote

It would be awesome if new seasons were each in a different country.

1

owowouch t1_j8wi2kp wrote

Pacing issues sure. But I love how nice and supportive and complimentary everybody is to each other (for the most part). A US version would be full of narcissist reality tv types -- either because of our cultural differences or because producers would cherrypick such personalities for added drama.

26

obitonye t1_j8wlw2o wrote

It can be easily.cut into one or two episodes. Pacing is very slow. Also their fighting was kinda funny. Watched first episodes on fast forward.

Sorry.

0

pieface100 t1_j8wu4d4 wrote

I am really enjoying this show! However, the editing in this show is incredibly frustrating. I don’t need to see everybody’s reaction to the same scene with the same shouts in the background 3 or 4 times in a row.

3

helava t1_j8x0w6h wrote

The pacing is slow. The way it’s edited is very “Korean reality TV”, which it is. But if you can deal with the pacing and the editing, it’s super compelling.

If you’re into Physical:100, you’ll almost certainly also like Run for the Money, also on Netflix. Japanese reality show about a bunch of people trapped in a Dutch-themed theme park and being hunted (tag). Same issues re: pacing and editing, but really fun and surprisingly tense.

37

Dalekdude t1_j8x67na wrote

My roommates been watching it so I’ve catched bits and pieces and joined her for some. Thought it was very funny when the speedy guy picked the strongest guy thinking he could outrun him with the “be the last one holding onto the ball” game only for the strong dude to lay on the ball for almost three minutes lol

17

vbob99 t1_j8xekx6 wrote

I feel like this could never work in North America, as the personalities wouldn't be willing to put it on the line and lose.

23

Don_Fartalot t1_j8xfip9 wrote

Best thing about this show is the lack of sob stories. No 'I came on this show for my 2 kids and wife who is dying of cancer', just (mostly) respect and camaraderie between the contestants.

54

JelliedBoat t1_j8xofhr wrote

My roommates and I are obsessed with it, there’s few things more impactful than watching someone destroy a bust of their own chest with the equal weight of pride and shame.

3

lordatlas t1_j8xvw8u wrote

Yes, I absolutely love it when everything is repeated three times for effect. Three times for effect. Three times for effect.

0

changspanx t1_j8y35d8 wrote

I watch it and I am loving it. Honestly, the best part beyond the physicality is how supportive the athletes are of each other. But I do watch it with my finger hovering over the FF button. Really slow but worth the time

9

typingblackbelt t1_j8ytueg wrote

The physical challenges are interesting enough if you can manage to suffer through the reality television pageantry. So over produced with repeating clips that attempt to manufacture some sort of tension.

When I do watch it, it is with my hand on the remote, thumbing the fast forward button.

2

[deleted] t1_j8z9hmk wrote

It's so stupid though.

Like I've only watched 3/4 episodes, but you have people >!picking strong opponents rather than picking weak opponents for the challenges,!< why on Earth would you do that if you're supposed to be competing for a big pile of money.

And also, some of the results aren't believable, like in the challenge where they have to >!wrestle the ball off your opponent. Where a woman beats a man in an arena where there's zero cover so you can't run away or anything.!<

There is no way that legitimately happens and they just glossed over it like it was nothing.

And things are too slow. We don't need need loads of replays of uninteresting things and we don't need so much of the dull parts of the games and the episodes are too long for what they are. They could have done with speeding the pace up a bit and overall streamlining the show, but as I say I've only watched 3/4 episodes so maybe that gets better as there's less contestants.

They should have had two competitions running simultaneously (one for men one for women) or something, would have been better.

−6

Enraiha t1_j8zlj59 wrote

Hardcore ice climbers are in a league of their own, like free soloers. Just amazing overall athletes. Similar to rock climbers being the most successful on things like America Ninja Warrior.

11

jl_theprofessor t1_j8zysik wrote

I saw the title of this post and laughed out loud. My parents just arrived in town today. I'm with my mom in my kitchen and I'm like "where's dad?" I go to check out what he's watching and I'm watching just a room full of Koreans dangling from these bars, holding on for dear life so they don't drop into the water. I walk by later and some farmer is getting choked the eff out while they wrestle for a ball. And my dad was just eyes locked onto it. I made so many fly bys of the TV that I was just like "fuck it I'm going to my office to watch this on my PC."

13

ScaredSpace7064 t1_j8zzh9v wrote

I'm thoroughly hooked and I don't mind the pacing. It gives me a little extra time to enjoy it. Been recommending it to everyone I know. My brother is Korean bilingual (which is pretty dang amusing given he's a White American tech bro) and he loves the banter among the athletes.

6

CarbonShmarbon t1_j905dg6 wrote

This is my annoyance with the show. Reactions in triplicate. I get that reaction videos are a thing in society now but it almost stopped me watching it. This aside, I have been enjoying it more as it has progressed and I feel like they have chilled out on the repeated Waaaaaaaahhh!s to some extent.

1

Haunting-Bonus1543 t1_j90e8e1 wrote

Good competition premise but the editing is horrific. The constant double and triple takes of every little move or screaming reaction is super annoying and makes getting through an episode quite challenging.

2

Sada_sama t1_j91sjau wrote

Yeah I feel like there wouldn't be as much respect. One of my favorite parts about the show is the sportsmanship and respect everyone has for one another. I was really disappointed when >!miracle!< pushed the guy in front of him. Really felt like it tarnished the idea of the competition for me

19

wethairlady t1_j93s7th wrote

I can’t remember any of the women on the show picking “the biggest strongest guy to challenge” so would appreciate if you could specify.

Do you mean the part where >!Bo-mi-rae volunteered for the punishment of Sisyphus? Because I thought it was clear the reason she did that was because no one on her team was suitable for an explosive strength challenge and would be better utilised elsewhere so she essentially sacrificed herself. She knew she was gonna get wreaked and was an absolute champ about it!<

11

Fit-Till-738 t1_j94uo87 wrote

I'm not sure if it's the translation, the editing, or a characteristic of the people who tend to be on the show, maybe even a cultural thing, but they all seem so self depreciating. Very hard on themselves for mistakes that anyone would make, especially considering how fit and skilled they are. I appreciate how quick they are to compliment and support each other. Sure, some were kind of dbags, but I think they all got cut in the first few elimination challanges. Does anyone else notice this, or is it just me? I lived in South East Asia for a while, and I know that being selfish and unsportsmanlike are highly looked down on, but I never saw the same level of self debasement...

1

wethairlady t1_j95e3th wrote

Ok thank you - that’s one example. Are there any more?

I actually really enjoyed that fight. I knew she wasn’t going to win but to see her topple someone so much bigger and heavier than her a couple of times was really impressive.

3

vbob99 t1_j95r5ol wrote

The Challenge has people you learn about for being on The Challenge, not people you would think beforehand when you hear about a show like that. So for instance, you wouldn't see Terry Crews, really buff guy, on a show like this as he wouldn't risk the hit to his image of losing. (sorry... Terry Crews is an incredibly nice guy it seems, his name just popped into my mind immediately).

5

vbob99 t1_j98l04x wrote

Select athletes. It's like having an exhibition chess world championship, but the top players not coming out because they have nothing to gain and everything to lose.

1

MrDozens t1_j99dp28 wrote

One thing they have to change is the ring from in the first elimination. It’s extremely dangerous with the small 1 foot high steel ring. I saw one of the contestant almost got his hand slam on it. Make taller than the people at least like in MMA.

1

wethairlady t1_j99qcmr wrote

Well that’s your perspective. As a small woman I find it impressive because I know how hard it is to even budge someone that much bigger and he fell pretty hard. Even if you’re taking it easy that doesn’t change your weight and height.

2

eoljjang t1_j9bixhk wrote

Definitely cultural! I have watched Korean variety/reality shows for years and the editing is usually way worse sometimes they’ll replay things 4 times. It’s annoying but the shows are still great despite that haha

12

Popular-Departure222 t1_j9dh1bz wrote

Yeah it's an Asian thing. Their sport and who they represent is bigger than themselves. They uphold themselves to that standard. The debasing is motivation to get back and grind. I'm Asian and I've noticed this difference in athletes. Especially since I also watch the NBA.

Sometimes the ego is also necessary to reach godhood.

3

28stabwoundz t1_j9dmqex wrote

Can you actually give us an instance of when this happened? Personally I dont see why ur maken a deal about it cause its honestly sounds more like they wanted a challenge which is pretty brave. I dont think its about being an idiot or overconfident these people are just the type of people who like to face and overcome massive hurdles. This enviroment was a good opportunity for them to see how they would fair against men. Yes maybe not strategic, but they gave it a shot for the competition and I think thats pretty cool especially how it is obvious they would be pummeled. And its a good spirit to have that their "proud" of themselves. What, do you want them to be completely ashamed and cry that they got beaten? None of the women were rude to the men or said anything sexist to them they just challenged them for their OWN benifit.

To me this sounds like "How dare a woman even think of challenging a man" she must be an arrogant piece of shit when its really not that deep.

Saying that the female contestants are arrogant is just comepltely misleading. From what I can see, the women always showed good sportsman ship and respect to their male contestents. I haven't watched all of the show so maybe I'm missing something but so far, there has been pretty good sportsman ship from both sides and what your saying seems like a nonexistant problem. Especially, when I have seen other males that are smaller and less compitent pick obviously larger more bulky male contestants but why dont they get hate for being "an idiot"?

I guess I could say the same for the males who chose females to go 1v1 against but since the world isn't black and white I can think that yes, they did it because they wanted to win even though others would see it as cowardly. Though I could argue that many of these male contestants were actually outright disrespecting their female oppontents by saying things like "She's just a woman if I cant defeat her I'm not a real man"...which is sort of lame? Not good sportsmanship. But OH no their ok i guess cause its strategy lol. These women are proud of themselves and have probably faced alot of sexism for their way of life but they have barely talked about it and have instead, used it as fuel to try out new challenges. Pretty admirable if you ask me.

12

wethairlady t1_j9f59ss wrote

I agree. Only one instance of a woman challenging a man has been presented (Park Min-ji, the wrestler taking on Jang Seong-min, the rugby player) unless more examples are brought forward then this claim that “some of the women are so overconfident” is a deceptive exaggeration. This may not have been intentional but I still find it sad as like you said there are more examples of grace and sportsmanship from the women contestants.

Specific examples being: >!Jang Eun-sil being very humble and surprised about being chosen as team leader instead of a man but still being determined to lead her team to victory. Kim Da Young getting her foot squashed between two large logs during the ship moving quest but insisting they quickly carry on with the task. As I’ve already mentioned in another comment Bo-mi-rae made a strategic sacrifice for her team during the Ancient Greek themed quest meanwhile on another team Song A-reum was realistic about her abilities so was happy letting the men take the lead in choosing who would compete in what rather than being “overconfident”.!<

To come back to Park Min-ji challenging Jang Seong-min and that making her an “idiot”, I think in that case we should also mention >!BBULK who in the same selection process made a show of taunting all the contestants instead of choosing strategically despite being one of the smaller men on the show. Ultimately Kim Sang-wook, a bigger stronger man and MMA fighter took him on and obviously won. Comparably I think it’s fair to say that BBULK displayed a far more overt overconfidence yet he does not get mentioned while Park Min-ji gets called an idiot. I’m almost certain if Park Min-ji had behaved the same way as BBULK had she would be getting an incredible amount of hate and ridicule.!<

I actually don’t think either of them are idiots though. While it’s speculative, to me this seems like both cases are producer influenced. They needed a cocky antagonist and at least one instance of a woman choosing a man just to spice things up a bit so BBULKUP and Park Min-ji filled those roles for screen time and to make the show more interesting which is strategic for a different purpose.

Ultimately both the women and men contestants are capable of incredible feats in athleticism as well as being incredible team players and I think that deserves respect.

7

joaofelix9 t1_j9f7k6l wrote

I don't think weight classes should be a thing in this show. It's the top 100 physiques going at it, if you're not well rounded and at least formidable in each category then you shouldn't win. Strength is one of them. Just like the strongmen might suck in agility-based games

6

hazyyy1 t1_j9hrf5x wrote

Not at all. The Challenge is mostly people who've become famous for being on the challenge. While 100 is about famous athletes/personalities/fitness people in korean are collected. If they continue with further seasons and invite previous 100 contestants back and after 20 years then yeah maybe we can make the comparisions.

3

hazyyy1 t1_j9hrmxm wrote

His point was that with Challenge 100, it was an collection of famous people whether they were athletes/personalities/fitness throughout korea. The challenge is mostly people who were famous through real world or road rules that evolved into "the challenge"

1

Gloomy-Bat-3157 t1_j9ine1r wrote

I think you are missing a big component of Korean culture and many eastern cultures generally speaking. Honor and respect are very important to them. Many contestants when given the opportunity to choose an opponent selected someone they thought would be a fair match. Many also felt pity and empathy for beating a contestant who was at an obvious disadvantage in a given game. Winning isn't everything to them.

9

Brodie9jackson t1_j9jy9kh wrote

It also wouldn’t work in NA because every major proffesional sports organization or first responder division (military, navy, and even fire etc.) wouldn’t allow their athletes or active members to participate. It would just be a shit mix of IG influencers and cross fit junkies.

The Beauty of the show being in Korea is you actually got ex-Olympians, MMA fighters, pro athletes and active serving machines, which offered a way more enjoyable experience. A North American version would just be trash TV IMO

10

No-shotHaha t1_j9kyhou wrote

I think it's fucking stupid due to the imbalance of challenges. Ice climber dude made it into top 5 then got fucked with the 5-way tug of war, shits completely unfair, if they made it a speed challenge he would've made it passed that round for example

2

IqRaterMan t1_j9n8n12 wrote

Thats ultimately the point of the show, though. To test for weaknesses in your physique. The most well rounded athletes are able to at least not be last place in any given event, which is how you advance. Ice climber dude needed to work on his brute strength, but even still, it ended up coming down to half a second. I dont see it as a problem.

3

Fit-Till-738 t1_j9ss0vg wrote

Some of those matches in the ball challenge were completely one-sided. Especially the body builders against dudes 100lbs lighter... That has nothing to do with being "well-rounded" and everything to do with sheer mass... That's like a tug of war between a VW beetle and a Mac truck...

2

Fit-Till-738 t1_j9sxqmx wrote

On the Sand court, there was no choice but to brawl. The smaller guys may have had the ability to run and dodge on the obstacle course, but they were stopped anyway because the huge guys threw the ball in the corner and made them brawl for it...

2

joaofelix9 t1_j9t09fk wrote

The smaller guys were able to choose the arena, it wasn‘t predetermined. Also, the only way for the bigger guy to hide the ball is because the smaller guys messed up and didn‘t retrieve the ball properly but ran over it. That‘s just their fault

3

doubletaps t1_j9yeece wrote

Should make one physical 100 international would be interesting to watch

2

LiveAd4073 t1_j9yrqrv wrote

yup, in that moment I was like....well that pretty much is the difference between Westerners and Easterners. Collectivism vs Indivisualism. Miracles Western fight to be the winner above all took over in that moment

3

LiveAd4073 t1_j9ys5ew wrote

Seeing people unfamiliar with Korea reality shows tlaking about the slow pacing is so interesting to me. This is by far one of the fastest paced reality shows I've ever seen come from Korea. And Squid Games was the fastest drama/episodic show I'd ever seen with such fast pacing. They've definitely been catering towards Western and younger audiences. Growing up, a drama would take 3 hours for them to a single love confession

6