Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Elothar_ t1_jcx6sqk wrote

First 3 seasons of TWD were much better than TLOU in my opinion. Sure the actors and the production design are incredible but the pacing is horrific and the lack of infected is an issue even though it’s centered around human psychology. I personally gave it a 7.5-8 out of 10 while TWD was easily a 9 at first It dips quickly to a shit show though aha

7

johnsmith4000 t1_jcxkhq7 wrote

To me TWD Season 2 succeeds in a lot of ways TLOU somewhat failed. Season 2 was a slow burn full of character intrigue and, crucially, enough infected to remind us of the ever-present danger lurking around every corner. This culminating in the horde scene in the season finale was perfect build-up. TLOU’s problems are definitely partially a result of the small number of episodes and the over-focus on side stories (I liked episode 3 and 7 quite a bit but in retrospect they wasted time there).

6

Dear-Ad1180 t1_jcx6zzp wrote

TWD is as generic as it gets. TLOU is already better than any walking dead season without any doubt

−4

pragmatick t1_jcxcm9f wrote

TLOU is not a zombie show, it's a show about love in a post-zombie world. TWD was much more of a zombie show and I enjoyed it for it. But I didn't expect TLOU to have a lot of infected as in the game you need stuff to shoot at between the story while in the show you can concentrate on the plot. FWIW they said season 2 will have more infected.

−4

jteg9 t1_jcxgo5p wrote

“a show about love in a post-zombie world”

I hope thats not the point of the show because thats fucking stupid

0

sara-ragnarsdottir t1_jcxl9nq wrote

This is simply the plot, the relationship between Ellie and Joel is the focus. But fans downplay the zombies part a lot. The gameplay is all about shooting the infected (and sometimes human) or trying to escape from them. They are a big part of TLOU and survival is not a minor issue in the game.

4

jteg9 t1_jcxoglf wrote

Its really frustrating how the show and its fans try to distance themselves from the zombie aspect almost like they are embarrassed of it. This isnt some literary masterpiece it is a video game adaption about the zombie apocalypse just fucking own it

8

sara-ragnarsdottir t1_jcxq3ys wrote

It's a ridiculous attitude and it comes from the (unfortunately) evergreen idea that genre fiction is just cheap entertainment and can't have anything, even remotely, interesting to say about the world etc.

The Last thing of Us IS an action/adventure game in third person where you have to hide from enemies or face them using firearms, and most of these enemies are zombies/infected. This is not an opinion, it's literally a fact. It's also the story of Ellie and Joel traveling together, through a world that is actively trying to kill them, and becoming each other's family. People who are saying otherwise need to get off their pedestal and admit that GASP they've been loving an action videogame where zombies play a pivotal part

5

onex7805 t1_jd6lf7b wrote

They did not capture the horror thriller or apocalyptic elements of the story that made their journey feel so dangerous. In the game they are pushed to the limits and that experience makes their bond so much stronger.

The danger, outside of the first clicker and the one swarm with the bloater, comes almost entirely from the other very few humans in the show. That is not in balance with the game. As a result Joel saving Ellie at the hospital didn’t have the same emotional effect the game had.

1

onex7805 t1_jd6l0lz wrote

The Last of Us is a zombie show lmao. Like, that's the whole point of the vaccine. If the world is not dangerous, why civilization couldn't thrive?

The infected barely feel like a threat 90% of the time so a cure feels a lot less urgent. If they had invented it, they'd still be dealing with almost everything they're dealing with now.

0