Submitted by EchoBay t3_11u38m6 in television
SwagginsYolo420 t1_jcmd46s wrote
The thing with The Last of Us is it had an unusually strong story for a game in the first place - which was on par with prestige TV quality already. Most games, even great ones, do not have that kind of detailed story.
A lot of games, even great ones, the narrative in the game play is much more open to interpretation or there's no specific linear narrative and character development beyond the player's imagination.
Half Life 2 for example, an amazing experience, and the Half Life IP calls for an adaptation due to its setting and lore. An adaptation would require the invention of new characters, conflicts, character arcs etc even if characters from the original made an appearance.
Game series such as Fallout or Bioshock or Metal Gear Solid even - which beg for a series adaptation - their strength is more in the world, lore and setting than specific character stories, and any adaptation would practically require an entirely new story and additional characters created for the medium.
So to me the main lesson is to take the material seriously, be respectful to the game and the setting and the lore. But most future great adaptations of games are going to require a lot more new storytelling, TLoU game was kind of a stand-out exception, as the story lends itself to a very straightforward re-telling.
young_mummy t1_jcnfwx6 wrote
I think God of War has a very good chance at striking gold for the same reasons.
shogi_x t1_jcpy0ko wrote
I would be inclined to agree, except that it's at Amazon which doesn't have the track record HBO does.
young_mummy t1_jcq7d0i wrote
Definitely agree. I meant more that the game itself has great potential as an adaptation. I don't have much faith that Amazon will be able to realize that potential though... If HBO picked it up I'd have much higher expectations.
They did at least bring on key people from the game to work on the show though. That's a good sign.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments