Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

GarlVinland4Astrea t1_iu43eet wrote

Reply to comment by HistoryQuestion69 in ‘Dahmer’ Stays In Top Spot Followed By ‘Hocus Pocus 2’ On Nielsen Streaming Chart by HumanOrAlien

  1. HOTD is not a show for kids and families

  2. The amount of written material on HOTD and the Second Age of LOTR is about the same. HOTD is based off a fake history book and it really doesn’t have a full narrative and when it does it contradicts itself with varying perspectives. Also the Silmarillion is mostly a first age work. Second Age is more defined in short stories, extensive appendices and materials written by Tolkien and what we know in the books when they talk about it

4