>A harfoot story? Fuck all the way off... A wandavision type story about gollum and the ring? Seriously fuck off... A telling of the first age? OK, but give it to Peter Jackson... You know, the guy who didn't rape the source material (we forgive him the hobbit because what he did with LOTR) , and give him the billion dollar budget.

Half the stuff people complain about in ROP as "terrible writing" is just as present in the Jackson films.