Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

meowskywalker t1_iy8adx6 wrote

It was too much House for me. I already watched a bazillion seasons of House, I didn’t need House Except He’s Got a Doctor’s Note to explain why he’s sometimes an asshole.

Plus “he’s a brilliant surgeon but he can’t be trusted to speak to patients” describes most surgeons. Just make sure someone is in the room to translate from autistic surgeon speak to patient speak and back. This is much less of a problem than the show insists it is.

3

bros402 t1_iy8djh6 wrote

> Plus “he’s a brilliant surgeon but he can’t be trusted to speak to patients” describes most surgeons. Just make sure someone is in the room to translate from autistic surgeon speak to patient speak and back. This is much less of a problem than the show insists it is.

yup, and it isn't an accurate protrayal of autism

they infantilize the main character and any disabled character who appears.

You think they'd at least have a disability consultant, but nooooooooope

1

Toidal t1_iy8xzdt wrote

Imo it's way more ensemble than House, the other characters have their own fairly fleshed out stories and arcs separate from Shawn's autism that span entire and through multiple episodes. Its very much "pretty doctors with problems" and one of them happens to be autistic. Compared to House where if Hugh's not in a scene, chances are the characters are talking about him or the case he put them on. Same with The Rookie, the hook is that he's an older new cop, but after the first season or 2 it rarely comes up again except as a gag occasionally and the storylines moved past that to be more ensemble

That being said, I haven't seen The Good Doctor in a while. I think I stopped at the end of the season where that blonde super ambitious doctor learned she has some genetic nerve disease that's going to ruin her hands and prevent her from being a surgeon later in life. Not that I think its a bad show, just not must see tv. The Rookie though was getting too ridiculous, it started great as like a more light hearted less gonzo The Shield, but then the main cast started getting way too personally involved in their own cases. Like Jesus how often does Nolan get kidnapped.

1

GenericAustin t1_iy89vng wrote

So it becomes better, I last watched the 9th episode of season 3 and I felt it wasn't worth continuing anymore. There were too many episodes and no endgame for me to look forward to.

2

bros402 t1_iy8d63w wrote

It doesn't get better, don't worry.

5

ArchDucky t1_iy8e0u9 wrote

I watched it for awhile. I had to stop when Wei Chan Will Yun Lee shows up as a former cop / new doctor. He keeps saying he used to be a cop and it pulls me out every time. Its not the actors fault, he just starred in one of the best open world games ever made. Maybe if he didn't say it so often it wouldn't bother me, but its practically how he starts conversations.

2

HiveMindKing t1_iy9fffk wrote

According to my dad who worked the ER, Medicine is much More like “We stabilized you by putting a stint in but if you don’t stop eating 5 cheeseburgers a day you are going to die in two years, do you understand”

-no

1

ThisGuy6266 t1_iy9iu1e wrote

Autism is not a super power.

1

bros402 t1_iy8dcn4 wrote

The show is baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad. Fucking horrible depiction of autism. It's disgusting with how inspiration porn-y it is

It is a great hate watch, though.

0