Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

StarshineSolid t1_iy6zy4v wrote

Dear God I disagree. Dark is a MASTERPIECE. 1899 is so disappointing I stopped watching it half way...


AnakinRagnarsson66 OP t1_iy70v85 wrote

Admitting that you gave up watching a show halfway through isn’t the boast you think it is. Especially one as well made and high quality and good as 1899


StarshineSolid t1_iy72i8g wrote

"1899" is a cruel disappointement and a terrible fail. I don't understand what went through Jantje Friese and Baran Bo Odar's minds. "Dark" blew my mind, episode after episode. It's a masterpiece and one of the best show of the past decade. But "1899" was fatally weak and boring and the scenario sucks. It's a low quality entertainment for housewives over 50 years old. It's not nearly as well written as "Dark" and it's adressed to a lazy audience, lacking depth and substance. The actors aren't good, there are plenty of flaws in the timeline, it seriously lack coherence. Now we both seem to enjoy Bo Odar's work, so I guess that's what matter. I believe we have two types of sensitivity, it is interesting to see where it differs and split. I am among the thousand of online viewers who were not sensitive to "1899". While "1899" is addressed to people who don't seem to notice inconsistencies or worst... are satisfied with them. Mass appeal, mass consumption audience. Not niche anymore.


AnakinRagnarsson66 OP t1_iy73ea5 wrote

You admitted yourself, you haven’t seen half of the show. So how can you judge if it has flaws in the timeline and lacks coherence? Ridiculous.


StarshineSolid t1_iy77l9q wrote

Read again ? I have seen half the show. 7 episodes and I stopped. It doesn't take 5 seasons to pin point flaws in timeline and lack of credibility. You can't take someone else's opinion because you are sadly immature. I am kindly interacting with you about having two different points of view but you're taking this with anger because you are childish and pressed that someone dares to disagree with you. Grow up little boy.


AnakinRagnarsson66 OP t1_iy8zn9t wrote

So you’ve seen 7 episodes, yet you claim to have stopped watching after only seeing half. 🧐 7/8 is not equal to 1/2. Explain to me your math here, because it just doesn’t add up.

Also who said I had any anger whatsoever?