Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Moose_Hooves t1_irssqja wrote

Do Indians embrace a national identity? Do they respect the authority of their national government?

It’s such a beautiful country with such an amazing history. I didn’t know this but apparently when the British arrived, India was the wealthiest nation in the world by a hige margin. To this day the people who own the most gold in the world are Indian houswives.

14

dragerslay t1_irtdbl2 wrote

India does have siginificant national identitiy, verging on nationalism. Strogn national identity was something pushed by governments since India's independance. Still there are large differences in food, language, religious practices and other cultural pillar between states, especially north vs. south.

13

pinkcheems t1_iruib0l wrote

Indians always embraced a national identity. It was unfortunate that India failed to unite under one king in the history. The connecting link between indian states was dharmic culture or religions. vishnu puran (sacred book in Hinduism which talks about life of vishu (krishna) mentions that उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्यः हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् ।

वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम: भारती यत्र संततिः ।। The country

that lies north of the ocean and south of the

snowy mountains is called Bhāratam (India);

there dwell the descendants of Bharata. So we can say that concept of India as nation is not new.

6

SeleucusNikator1 t1_irtj9d4 wrote

> I didn’t know this but apparently when the British arrived, India was the wealthiest nation in the world by a hige margin

Note that this depends on what you mean by "wealthiest". India was wealthy the same way China and the USA are wealthy today, but not wealthy in the sense that Switzerland is a country of rich people.

Before the Industrial revolution, virtually almost all of the population (across the world) would have been peasants living in pretty primitive conditions, be it in Qing China or in Habsburg Spain. Urban populations were only a tenth of the population at best, and the wealthy merchants within them would of course be an even smaller minority.

3

Moose_Hooves t1_irtje05 wrote

Of course, I was talking about the wealth held by India’s elite. Like their rich people were weakthier than any other nation’s rich people.

4

Extension_Ad6338 t1_irup8tn wrote

>Do Indians embrace a national identity? Do they respect the authority of their national government?

Yeah as we've been diverse way before you Westerners made it a trend to flex on

1

Smart_Sherlock t1_isgf35x wrote

India does not have any strong secessionist movement, except those openly funded by the PRC and Pakistan.

Indians in general are very strongly nationalistic. People may question the party of power in the Center, but will never raise questions on India as a State

1