Well, ultimately the school you attend will be decided on where you live. CVU or Essex will probably have the best chance to provide a successful team, but any school could be good at a random sport any year. Scorebooklive.com is where Varsity teams report their scores and track their record, so you can check out each school there if you're looking for a specific sport.

As for reputation, BHS is probably the lowest regarded of the group. They'll each have their good and bad aspects, but purely from reputation I would say BHS gets the short stick.

If you are moving to Vermont for athletics and you do anything but ski you will be profoundly disappointed unless you’re bad at sports because sports here are small time.