For my engagement/wedding rings, I went to After Midnight Jewelers in the blue mall in South Burlington. While my wife's ring was pretty standard (albeit beautiful), they did an amazing custom job on my ring. My father passed away some years before, and they incorporated some of the gold from his wedding band into mine. They also created two custom necklaces with the rest of the gold that I gave to my mother and sister. They did a great job and I highly recommend them!