I have to say, moving here from NY 15 years back and abandoning the BECSPK on the classic hard roll was difficult for most of my early years. I lived in Rutland initially but nothing could compare. The best I had down in that area came from Sunup Bakery in Killington.

Now I live in Middlebury and Middlebury Bagel is definitely a fantastic option. But - the best breakfast sandwich I have ever had in Vermont comes from Capitol Grounds in Montpelier. A very close second is (actually where CG acquires their bread) at the Red Hen Baking in Middlesex.