I’ll offer an off-the-wall suggestion, but you’d need to act quickly to secure the time. Rent the Cabin/Pavilion space at Mt. Philo State Park and hire a local caterer. JCAT, Bevo, Bluebird, and Mark BBQ, all are excellent for great home-style eats, and y’all can mosey to some great views or spread out. The cabin and pavilion make it pretty weather proof for both the meal and caterer as well. Easy access for older folks, too.

Another cool option is the pavilion at American Flatbread in Warren, but a more limited food selection, I’d imagine.

Michael’s and HotW are excellent, hands down, I don’t think you’d be disappointed.

As a wild card, if folks are more adventurous in their palette, Sushi Maeda has a huge space and the food is incredible. Lots of local ingredients are used there in non-traditional ways. Book them early and give Mike/Paddy/Nick time to plan.