Submitted by ThetaGangThroweway t3_zwj0ve in wallstreetbets
kifra101 t1_j1vqojq wrote
Reply to comment by ThetaGangThroweway in Why Interest Rates Should Stay High (ish). by ThetaGangThroweway
Look, by the end of Roman empire, their coin had less than 1% of the original gold content then when they were at the peak of the empire. Their purchasing power collapsed to the point that they left the safety of the empire to move outside the walls and survive on the land to feed themselves. This left them open to invaders later on.
They had taxes then as well. In fact, they realized after taxation that they did not have enough to sustain the extravagances of the city which is why they started money dilution to begin with. Enormous government spending eventually leads to collapse. The point I am making here is that our spending and debt have reached a point now where it is near unsustainable. Raising the interest rate to 7% or higher is no longer a practical reality because our real debt is substantially greater than they were in the Volcker-era. No amount of money printing will bring back the purchasing power of the dollar unless something changes -> supply chains explode, technology advances massively, energy becomes near abundant, etc.
ThetaGangThroweway OP t1_j1vsdyh wrote
Don't get me started on the fall of Rome, I could literally go on all day. Suffice it to say that was a symptom, not the cause, and their fiat currency kept prices stable even as the gold content fell. By the time Rome started losing territory, the population size across the empire had already fallen massively and the legions had been cannibalized in a list of ways long before then.
And regardless, that's not the proof you're looking for as deliberate inflation acts like a hidden tax on savings and we're not looking to increase spending, but rather change the manner in which we raise revenue. I.E. We can reduce inflation and raise income taxes for higher brackets, as long as net revenue is the same... Who cares?
kifra101 t1_j1vskzf wrote
I am just saying man, you should have studied economics more than history. LMAO.
ThetaGangThroweway OP t1_j1vsz5u wrote
You'd be surprised to the degree they overlap.
Also, literally the last class I finished was doctoral level history of US economics. I did my research paper on Wichita aerospace manufacture.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments