randoredirect t1_iu7jbul wrote on October 29, 2022 at 3:49 AM

Reply to comment by Groveshield in Controversial race researcher gets prestigious Cambridge University fellowship by hieronymusanonymous

Not really because circumstances do effect upbringing

Groveshield t1_iu7jntx wrote on October 29, 2022 at 3:52 AM

Yet AMERICANS who are of Jamaican ethnicity typically outperform their fellow Americans who are white at the absolute top of running competition?

You can literally just watch the fucking olympics to realize your opinion is beyond flawed.

If upbringing was what decided who the top 0.01% of competitors were in sheer sports of athleticism like track, you would see more diversity. But you dont. Because when a 1% advantage decides if you win or lose then every possible factor tends to matter.

[deleted] t1_iu7ndjx wrote on October 29, 2022 at 4:30 AM

[removed]

Synensys t1_iu8551b wrote on October 29, 2022 at 8:30 AM

We're Jamaicans all brought over from the same part of Africa?

ClimateCare7676 t1_iu892xb wrote on October 29, 2022 at 9:30 AM

It still can be heavily impacted by cultural component. Cultures that have heavy focus on football have more top football players, regions that emphasise fighter culture and invest a lot in wrestling sports have top wrestlers in the Olympic games. Cultures that practice running and have running as their top preference will focus on running and encourage this skill through training, financially and by trying to seek the people who have good characteristically for running through screenings. A person living overseas will still be at least somewhat impacted by their country of origin or by their culture through their family and identity. Natural advantage would mean little with no training, financial support or cultural encouragement.