ComicsNBigBooks

ComicsNBigBooks t1_jdgfbin wrote

Not just from book fans, but pretty much fans of anything. I'm more selective with how frequently I interact or even what I share my opinion on these days, but fortunately, the older I get, the harder it is for me to be emotionally invested in online strangers' opinions about my opinion. And I say that not to be dismissive, but rather as someone who used to be very sensitive regarding this.

256

ComicsNBigBooks t1_jddn43g wrote

5 stars- one of the best books I've ever read/one of my favorites of all-time.

4 stars- very enjoyable; would probably read again

3 stars- decent enough one-time read

2 stars- didn't hate it but don't like it either

1 star- avoid at all costs

1

ComicsNBigBooks t1_j6gpdih wrote

Eh, I doubt it's a disorder. None of those books you named are particularly light, easy reads. I remember it taking me a while to get into Lord of the Rings (I was 15 when I read it, 29 now), and even once I was finished I'm not sure I had a full appreciation for the writing style. It's one I plan to go back to. Whereas with Game of Thrones/ASOIAF, I loved the first 3 books while taking a lot of time with them, trudged through the 4th and DNFed the 5th.

Like others have said, maybe try a less ambitious undertaking and see if you like it. I know it's one of the go-to books to name, but I read the first Mistborn book and loved it, and I'm currently on Well of Ascension (book 2). It's just deep enough with its lore/magic system but not extraordinarily complex or heavy, for me at least, and the writing helps with that.

1

ComicsNBigBooks OP t1_iu4olo8 wrote

Fair enough. I guess I wasn't looking for believability when I read it. I thought there was a delicious irony in Edmond being able to rebuild himself from scratch after being in prison for all those years, and that the more powerful he is emphasizes all the more how much he lost (Mercedes, his father, Morrel Sr.).

2

ComicsNBigBooks OP t1_iu4hst4 wrote

Second-ing this! I read the book over the course of about 3 months. There were times where I was tempted to just fly through to the ending, but I kept prolonging it and believe it definitely enhanced my reading experience. The story just feels much more rewarding over a gradual period of time versus binge reading it; you truly feel the years that have passed and the gravity of the story's events.

3

ComicsNBigBooks OP t1_ity0beq wrote

That's part of the tragedy of the story for me. Because of him being wrongfully imprisoned and having what was to be the best moment of his life ripped out from under him, Edmond (upon learning who was responsible) becomes solely fixated on revenge. So, by that point, there's no longer enough room for Mercedes in his heart, at least not until she comes to him pleading to spare her son. But his actions weren't for Mercedes, they were solely for himself.

2

ComicsNBigBooks OP t1_itp6vas wrote

I thought so, though I can't tell if you're saying that's a good or bad thing (or neither).. This is my first post ever in this group, as someone who rarely ever posts to reddit. Any similarity to other posts is purely coincidental, and since the book has a reputation as a classic and a must-read, I guess it's bound to happen. I imagine out of all the people who read this book, the amount of people who post about it still pales in comparison.

1

ComicsNBigBooks OP t1_itomj3e wrote

I love this comment! I had been planning to read it for awhile with some urging, and then just finally took the plunge. It wasn't long before I was hooked and, for me, it never let up. Also, it really hit me at the perfect time in my life. I look forward to many re-reads of it down the line as well. :-)

1

ComicsNBigBooks OP t1_ito4xfp wrote

Fair enough, I've heard this sentiment from people who don't love the book and I understand it. That said, I feel differently. I love everything in between, seeing the mental "chess matches" the Count is playing and trying to figure out his intentions, how he's gaining the faith of all the players on his chess board. I absolutely love all of it and found it riveting. And then the ending really sticks the landing. But I can understand how some would check out around the time he returns to France.

2