You could check the rebuttal process. Reviewers and authors discussed many rounds. Reviewers said concerns are not addressed. It is really ridiculous to say reviewers are outdated.
This is not real. You could check the reviewer and the author have discussed many rounds. The reviewers said the concerns are not addressed. I am very confused why ac said the reviewers are outdated!!
are you sure this is allowed? data leakage... really funny. I can also post a very very good results to cheat the review and then say I am sorry there is data leakage here.
Even_Stay3387 OP t1_iyw3rb4 wrote
Reply to comment by UnusualClimberBear in [D] Score 4.5 GNN paper from Muhan Zhang at Peking University was amazingly accepted by NeurIPS 2022 by Even_Stay3387
You could check the rebuttal process. Reviewers and authors discussed many rounds. Reviewers said concerns are not addressed. It is really ridiculous to say reviewers are outdated.