LordXenu45

LordXenu45 t1_jcm970p wrote

  1. Having someone from the games working actively on the show.
  2. Having the showrunner/writers genuinely care about the material.
  3. Mostly following the major beats of the story, expanding/changing as needed for a TV medium.

Then of course being somewhere like HBO with a good budget helps considerably as well but I really believe LoU succeeded because of those three points. Neil and Craig make a fantastic team and it really showed.

2

LordXenu45 t1_j6d0uxy wrote

If you thought the first two episodes were slow it might not be for you. Keep in mind the teens were stranded for over a year and a half, and the writers have a 5 season outline, so it's going to have some build-up before the real crazy stuff happens.

That said, I do think it continued to improve as the season went along. There are a lot of interesting characters in the show and the overall mystery in the adult storyline is pretty solid. However, I was hooked just from the first episode so take that as you want.

2

LordXenu45 t1_j23p4g8 wrote

Gonna admit I don't know how to gage it but I don't believe so. It's about as popular as it was pre pandemic, meaning there's absolutely a huge demographic for it and I don't want to act like it's not "popular" but I don't think Covid got more people into it. Maybe though, I really don't know lol

1

LordXenu45 t1_j1phhib wrote

Mr. Robot. So many people unfortunately bailed during the odd (but important) slow burn season 2 and never got the beautiful payoff.

The Leftovers as well. Season 1 is so dark and bleak but it really transformed into something magnificent with the last two seasons.

35

LordXenu45 t1_ixt9439 wrote

As far as just straight dramas go if The Wire didn't exist Mr. Robot would be my personal pick for TV GOAT. I agree with the general consensus season 2 is a bit too slow, but the pay off is worth it and I don't have a bad thing to say about 1, 3, or 4.

To think about the way that show starts and then where it ultimately leads... just a remarkable journey. It's batshit, it's thought provoking, and it's wrapped up in such a perfect way that I really do think it deserves to be up there with the best. Crazy it aired on USA Network lol

6