MartinScorsese

MartinScorsese t1_j6i3qv0 wrote

> Just because you can give a name to a character trope doesn't mean the whole surrounding film is bad as a result.

Well, yes, except this film is entirely about one man's growth - with a young woman as the primary catalyst for it - and when said catalyst is unrealistic, then the whole endeavor rings false.

> using subtleties and symbolism

There's nothing subtle in Garden State.

> The overall result is still a good film that can elicit emotion.

Bad movies can still be manipulative.

0

MartinScorsese t1_j6i0dft wrote

I think Garden State has some strong images, but it has not aged well. Once you realize that Natalie Portman's character is a Manic Pixie Dream Girl, the whole thing kind of falls apart.

EDIT: I should also add that Portman fulfills a similar role in Beautiful Girls, which I think is a better movie.

−1

MartinScorsese t1_j5z0zos wrote

Historically that's not true. Shakespeare in Love, Terms of Endearment, Annie Hall, The Apartment, and Marty all won Best Picture, to say nothing of acting awards for As Good As It Gets, The Goodbye Girl, Silver Linings Playbook, etc.

EDIT: Highly amused by the "those don't count" replies.

−15

MartinScorsese t1_j5k91pq wrote

Restaurant Week is over, which should cut down on people complaining about a struggling industry they never cared about supporting in the first place.

−1

MartinScorsese t1_j28q3qe wrote

> I think anyone could spot the enormous red flags. No major spoilers, but in the first 10 minutes, a man gets pooped on, in graphic fashion, by an elephant, and a completely different man in a completely different situation gets peed on by a woman.

Counterpoint: those are big reasons why Babylon rules.

> The commercials and trailers for this movie make it look like a four-quadrant movie that you’d want to take your grandma to see.

I'm sorry, that's just factually not true. The trailer includes scenes of characters snorting coke off of strippers.

1

MartinScorsese t1_j255ti2 wrote

I'm sorry to hear about your father.

My dad let me see Aliens when I was six. It gave me nightmares for years. After that, though, we saw tons of "adult" movies together in the theater when I was a teenager. In particular, I remember Fight Club, Good Will Hunting, American Beauty, and Jackie Brown.

5

MartinScorsese t1_j1yxilg wrote

I've been to the RI Ave location several times, and it's always been a delight. I wouldn't judge your experience solely over a holiday weekend, since that is one of the busiest times for theater workers everywhere.

> though if we do we now know we don’t need to bother paying for tickets

I look forward to the post here where someone tries to see a movie, and they're disrupted by thieves occupying their assigned seats.

45

MartinScorsese t1_j1vkyhm wrote

Keating was a scapegoat, not the culprit, and everyone looked for blame to assign because it's easier to be angry than to deal with grief. And contrary to your analysis, it was ultimately Neil who made that choice for himself.

7

MartinScorsese t1_iy84133 wrote

> Thank you, I would like to hear your reasoning for saying no.

For as long as horror films have been around, they have used scary characters and situations as metaphors, exploring our most primal anxieties and fears. One of the most common fears is losing our minds, or sense of self. If anything, Smile empathizes with mental health struggles.

1

MartinScorsese t1_iy835lv wrote

> Do movies like Smile (2022) further stigmatize mental health?

No.

> On a side note, has anyone noticed that most of the movies in which protagonist is going insane and is affected by it, 90 % if the cases are showed to be women.

I don't think this is the case at all, for two reasons.

  1. It is fairly common to see films about men struggling with mental health. The Banshees of Inisherin, The Fabelmans, The Good Nurse, Close, and Spiderhead are good recent examples.

  2. In many films where the female protagonist "goes insane," she is actually completely rational and in an extraordinary or supernatural situation. This is not "casual sexism," but often a comment on the nature of gaslighting (2020's The Invisible Man is a great example of this).

9