NoOne3051
NoOne3051 OP t1_j0wgdr6 wrote
Reply to comment by karake in [D] AAMAS 2023 Review Discussion by NoOne3051
for this year? 6 says that good paper but won't mind if rejected because of lower acceptance rate.
​
Then probably its a reject for me?
NoOne3051 OP t1_j0s81g7 wrote
Reply to [D] AAMAS 2023 Review Discussion by NoOne3051
I got 6, 6, 4. Whats the usual acceptance for AAMAS? I don't know what 7 rating is?
NoOne3051 OP t1_j0wktl0 wrote
Reply to comment by karake in [D] AAMAS 2023 Review Discussion by NoOne3051
Hmm :(. I hope the one with 4 changes his review. He just said my paper lacks theory (its an empirical paper with novel formulations for most part where we adapations of SOTA algorithms.). I hope meta reviewer sees it. There were no other concerns raised by reviewers (very short reviews as compared to ones I get for my other papers at NeurIPS, AAAI)