__pringles__
__pringles__ t1_ixd4aok wrote
Reply to [D] AISTATS 2023 reviews are out by von_oldmann
Any guide on the norms of writing a rebuttal? This is my first time writing one, so sample rebuttals will be really appreciated!
__pringles__ t1_ixbd4tb wrote
Reply to [D] AISTATS 2023 reviews are out by von_oldmann
64673
7 has confidence 2, rest all are of confidence 4.
The reviews are really well thought out, and recommend some good experiments, also highlight some weaknesses. Some also praise the cleverness and intuitiveness of the idea, and already thorough experiments!
I guess the new experiments will take some time to finish and update (one even asked for a user study!), so not sure whether I will be able to put new results in the rebuttal. But I suppose, the suggestions could make it a stronger submission next time! Does providing new supporting results really help during the rebuttal?
__pringles__ t1_izmy2t3 wrote
Reply to LPT: When bringing a dessert to a function, cut a small slice off before you put it out. by arkobsessed
This is actually a gamechanger. I had been to a group dinner recently, and there was a pizza on the table. NO ONE WANTED TO BE THE ONE TO TAKE THE FIRST SLICE! But when I took one triangle out, others jumped in right away. It’s incredible how these oblivious psychological tricks work!