In that case definitely depends on which games you want more. I will say xbox game pass has so many good games, including many of the big titles as well

If you're not much of a hardcore gamer I'd just get a secondhand Xbox one or PS4 before spending all that money on a system you dont even know if you'll like. You make really good points for getting either, which I also considered myself and I ended up on xbox one because more of the titles i wanted were on xbox rather than the 2 games I wanted on ps4