hardman52
hardman52 t1_jd6ot6q wrote
Reply to comment by KBSMilk in In-depth interview with Gregg Caruso, free-will skeptic by fatsosis
But we can't help but punish him. It's our fate, right?
hardman52 t1_jd6ez9x wrote
Reply to comment by KBSMilk in In-depth interview with Gregg Caruso, free-will skeptic by fatsosis
Well if there's no free will then we can't help but choose to punish criminals. And since they have no free will but continue to be anti-social, then we have no choice but to lock them up or execute them.
See the kind of problems you get into when you discuss free will on this shallow basis?
hardman52 t1_jdmsrvs wrote
Reply to comment by KBSMilk in In-depth interview with Gregg Caruso, free-will skeptic by fatsosis
How can intent exist without free will?