harrisc42

harrisc42 t1_jadpjzh wrote

Dave is wrong, from a financial perspective. You sound like you're fully aware of the problem with your debt. So you should tackle it head on by paying off the highest interest debt first.

The only people who should follow Dave's approach are the very ignorant and/or financially immature people who are only motivated to keep paying off their debt by seeing one of their accounts go to zero and feeling good about it.

2

harrisc42 t1_j6e3xhn wrote

No one can tell you which portfolio will do better over the next 5 years.

Portfolio A is riskier so if the markets are kind, it'll do better than B. But the tradeoff is a higher likelihood that they could make nothing or even lose a little bit.

If they aren't sure what to do, they can split the difference and go with a 50/50 portfolio which would almost certainly not lose money in a 5-year time frame.

1