meteoseeker t1_itr0ozd wrote on October 25, 2022 at 5:49 PM Reply to [D] AAAI 2023 Reviews by CauseRevolutionary59 got (7655)，chances? T T three novelty good, one novelty poor; all agree with: method effective, proved by extensive experiment 7 knowledgable, somewhat confident. 2 weaknesses, easy to answer 6 very knowledgeable, quite confident. give many positive comments. leave two questions, not easy to discuss. 5 somewhat knowledgable, not very confident. novelty poor, want direct proof of our idea which is hard T T. a misunderstood weakness (can be answered) 5 knowledgable, Somewhat confident. question some flaws of the techniques (very difficult to answer, and there are only 5000 characters... ) Permalink 1
meteoseeker t1_itr0ozd wrote
Reply to [D] AAAI 2023 Reviews by CauseRevolutionary59
got (7655)，chances? T T
three novelty good, one novelty poor; all agree with: method effective, proved by extensive experiment
7 knowledgable, somewhat confident. 2 weaknesses, easy to answer
6 very knowledgeable, quite confident. give many positive comments. leave two questions, not easy to discuss.
5 somewhat knowledgable, not very confident. novelty poor, want direct proof of our idea which is hard T T. a misunderstood weakness (can be answered)
5 knowledgable, Somewhat confident. question some flaws of the techniques (very difficult to answer, and there are only 5000 characters... )