I agree about my taste in movies ; my wife does not :p Ok, since your and my tastes seem to align, here's some of my other favourite horror movies, perhaps you'll find a few more new ones to enjoy:

• Evil Dead Series

• Evil Dead Remake

• Paranormal Activity 1-3

• Ouija: Origin of Evil (not the first Ouija, which is not good)

• Annabelle: Creation (none of the other Annabelle movies)

• The Descent

• Drag Me to Hell

• Behind the Mask

• The Invisible Man (from a couple years ago)

• The Mist

• It Follows

• Oculus

Ah yeah, I remember enjoying Identity.

A few more for you: The Innkeepers, Autopsy of Jane Doe, The Possession of Hannah Grace, The Others

No particular order: The Thing, The Shining, 1408, The Fall, Vile, Splinter, 10 Cloverfield Lane, Exam, Right at your Door, [Rec], Misery, You're Next, The Shallows, Barbarian, Deadstream, The Menu, Grave Encounters, Triangle, Fermat's Room