shanoshamanizum
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n1v6g wrote
Reply to comment by TiredOldLamb in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
I don't need answers I need raw information to analyze myself.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n1mdx wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
I don't need to believe anything else but the concept. Everything else is fixable and new providers are solving this.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n15a3 wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
How to explain it better. I don't need answer generators. I want raw content I can analyze myself.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n10ya wrote
Reply to comment by Plantarbre in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
Yet it makes the choices on my behalf which is the core problem.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n0yav wrote
Reply to comment by bigUKRAINIANcock in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
Spot on. The content still exists - https://ipfs-search.com/#/ and it's not totally doomed as long as we value it.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n0l9f wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
This doesn't defeat the problem with something making a decision on my behalf.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n0dp4 wrote
Reply to comment by khrisrino in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
Of course, I agree with that and new search engines without caveats are built such as - https://ipfs-search.com/#/ which is not centralized. If the concept is alive new providers will come.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mzfcy wrote
Reply to comment by khrisrino in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
We are comparing the concepts not the misbehavior of providers.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mz9yd wrote
Reply to comment by bigUKRAINIANcock in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
We are comparing the concepts not the behavior of providers. Indexed content choice vs an algorithm choosing the source for you.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mz1c0 wrote
Reply to comment by bigUKRAINIANcock in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
It's not about AI vs search engines it's about indexed user content vs officially approved single source of truth.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6myliy wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
That's still choice and I use it.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mye1f wrote
Reply to comment by shanoshamanizum in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
Yes officially approved and stamped right. The single source of truth. The dream of any dictatorship.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mya35 wrote
Reply to comment by SvijetOkoNas in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
That's exactly the choice you don't have with AI.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6my8sx wrote
Reply to comment by IndyDude11 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
But there are secondary answers to many questions.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mxsit wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
Even if the index puts an article on page 100 I can still read it. With AI I have no choice.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mxoky wrote
Reply to comment by Omegawop in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
So is any personal opinion but you have multiples of them and this is how you decide.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mxesx wrote
Reply to comment by khrisrino in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
>The AI has been trained on a large corpus of data (scraped from the internet I guess?). Search engine has also been trained on a large selection of data from the internet. So what’s the difference ultimately?
One is an index where ultimately you decide what to read while the other one is a crystal ball with no alternative options.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mx969 wrote
Reply to comment by DontTrustAnthingISay in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
The real problem starts when we have an extraordinary situation where people have no idea what's going on and the only answer you get is from wikipedia and officials. That's when we're in big trouble when it comes to free society.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mwyp2 wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
The choice is there. I am not saying search engines are the best. All I am saying is the concept of user crowdsourced content will always be more real than an algorithm choosing from approved sources only.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mwf9z wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
Can you host a website and get it indexed? Is that not free choice still compared to AI which cites only official approved sources?
Having a single source of truth has always been called dictatorship and censorship.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mw2sv wrote
Reply to comment by slimaq007 in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
There you go - choice. Which doesn't exist with AI.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mvct7 wrote
Reply to comment by Plantarbre in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
The question in discussion is freedom of choice for the user. There is no freedom in receiving a single answer to anything.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mvbgn wrote
Reply to comment by SvijetOkoNas in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
The question in discussion is freedom of choice for the user. There is no freedom in receiving a single answer to anything.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6mv795 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
You still have the choice though.
shanoshamanizum OP t1_j6n2rc7 wrote
Reply to comment by TiredOldLamb in Why AI can not replace search index by shanoshamanizum
Putting it this way I can see more clearly the similarity between both and the fact that maybe search engines are already using AI.