5--love this, would pre-order the author's next one, possibly in hardover

4--really good, highly recommended

3--Okay--reasonably well-crafted, but there were things I disliked

2--Not for me, but may have redeeming qualities

1--Probably didn't finish and I don't think anyone should bother.

There are moments of brilliance, but I really found the last two a slog, not to mention predictable.

I read it at 17 and wasn't impressed. I can barely recall anything about it year later.