userwithoutnam
userwithoutnam t1_itb0udr wrote
Reply to [D] AAAI 2023 Reviews by CauseRevolutionary59
How do people make a strong rebuttal in only 5000 characters?
I have to answer 12 questions. This leaves ~50-100 words per answer. Do people ignore some questions and focus on more important questions?
Am I missing something?
userwithoutnam t1_itakqzr wrote
Reply to comment by Tokemon66 in [D] AAAI 2023 Reviews by CauseRevolutionary59
Is there a rebuttal guideline at all?
userwithoutnam t1_it8k3uv wrote
Reply to [D] AAAI 2023 Reviews by CauseRevolutionary59
Is the rebuttal really limited to 5000 characters? This is hardly enough to respond to a single reviewer, let alone 4. This is such a disappointment compared to NeurIPS, where the rebuttal/author discussion format was significantly more pleasurable to deal with.
userwithoutnam t1_it7p9pf wrote
Reply to [D] AAAI 2023 Reviews by CauseRevolutionary59
Is there a guide and/or latex template for the rebuttal? Or do we simply submit raw text in the "post author feedback" text box?
I did not receive any email correspondence from AAAI (my co-author made the original submission but is unavailable for the review period).
userwithoutnam t1_itd4tx1 wrote
Reply to comment by Tokemon66 in [D] AAAI 2023 Reviews by CauseRevolutionary59
The rebuttal submission text box only allows for 5000 *characters*, which is hardly sufficient to rebut 4 reviews.